Montauk, New York, is a sleepy resort hamlet all the way east past New York City. Fortune Magazine even rated Montauk as the most expensive beach destination in the US back in 2017. That said, don’t let the label deter you from discovering Montauk’s beauty. Visitors get treated to wonderful seafood caught from the Atlantic. Montauk is also sandwiched between six state parks, including Shadmoor State Park and Montauk Point State Park, attracting plenty of hikers and nature lovers to visit. If you’re planning a getaway here, you can find plenty of beautiful designer and historical homes to stay at as well. For accommodation options, check out our list of the top mansion rentals in Montauk, New York.
We handpicked these listings carefully, considering (wherever possible) host status, recent guest reviews, location, accommodation type, prices, availability of dates, decor, and amenities. The image galleries get refreshed with the latest updates regularly. They were last updated on April 13, 2024.
1. Hither Hills Beach Haven (from USD 2526)
Hither Hills Beach Haven is an exquisite mansion nestled close by Hither Woods Preserve, giving it a secluded woodland feel even with the presence of neighboring buildings. Peer out to gaze at the surroundings from anywhere on the wraparound terrace. During sunny days, you can sit back and relax by the heated pool, preferably with a drink in hand. Inside, you can enjoy the warmth and light of the sun as it floods in from the tall windows that fill the walls of the home.
The master bedroom is fitted with a thick king bed, while all others have a slightly smaller yet comfy queen bed. For meals, you can make full use of the chef’s kitchen and also the barbecue grill.
Premier Host
2. Montauk Panorama (from USD 1360)
Montauk Panorama sits on a hill overlooking the sea, providing guests with an open and unobstructed view of the Atlantic’s waters from the comforts of the estate’s grounds. Spend a day sunbathing on the deck loungers, watching the waves and ships go by. Spend the cold nights socializing in front of a crackling fireplace, sharing stories with friends and family. There is also a game room and a media room, where you can spend your rainy or snowy day in.
For dining, the chef’s kitchen features copious amounts of space to work with, as well as a multi-burner stove so you can cook everything all at once.
Top guest reviews
Read more reviewsAmenities & Room:
we had plenty of room to stretch out and we lucked out with beautiful weather during our stay
3. Ocean View Oasis (from USD 1510)
Ocean View Oasis features a delightful shingle house with a majestic view of the ocean. The rustic modern look creates a lovely contrast that evokes both luxury and ruggedness. The kitchen comes well-stocked and fitted with sturdy stainless steel appliances.
Spend your holiday sipping drinks while wading in the deck’s heated infinity pool, taking a dip in the sunken hot tub for additional stress relief. You could also run a movie marathon in the home theater, making full use of the sound system rigged throughout the whole house.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
most time spent at the home on back deck while enjoying heated pool and hot tubthis is a spacious home with a beautiful pool and hot tub and huge deck overlooking the atlantic oceanCleanliness:
well-managed property and very cleanHost:
the team was responsive when we had any questions regarding the houseRead more reviewsLocation:
great location clean amazing home
4. 46 Edison Drive (from USD 1442)
This mansion rental is a great choice if you fancy yourself a large home with plenty of frontier aesthetics. Each bedroom is well-appointed but offers a rugged wooden appearance that makes you feel like you’re settling into wild country. The kitchen and dining area look more modern but still maintain the wood lodge aesthetics of the rest of the house. The home gym has exercise mats so you can maintain your yoga, aerobics, or even Zumba routines.
Outside, there’s a small swimming pool area that’s meant more for relaxing than keeping fit. If you’re planning to catch a tan, it’s better to do so on the wooden deck as that area is wider and has more loungers to lie down on.
Top guest reviews
Read more reviewsCleanliness:
the house was very clean and the pictures were accurate
5. Lovely mansion with kid-friendly features (from USD 850)
More than just a rental mansion, this property feels more like a dream family home because of all the wonderful features both kids and adults will love. The living room follows an open-plan design, with a massive 65" TV to keep kids busy while mom and dad fix dinner in the kitchen. Outside, there’s a private walkway that leads to the beach.
The swimming pool has shallow ends on opposite sides, making it much more safer and fun for kids about to take their first swim. The yard is also spacious, giving plenty of room for active games such as tag or water pistol fights. For the grownups seeking a bit of me time, they can steal away a private moment in the hot tub.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
great property with a private fenced backyard and a beautiful pool and hot tubHost:
carter is the best host you can ask forcarter was a great host attentive to what we neededvery nice and helpful ownerthank you so much carter and kate for hosting usthe home was toddler friendly and our family was quite comfortable during our stayRead more reviewsLocation:
great location to town and beachabsolutely beautiful house with perfect location for montauk’s beach and townloved this property perfect location and setting for a girls getawaythe beach is a quick walk away easy for multiple visits every day
6. Bright and vibrant family home with pool (from USD 1086)
Spend your Montauk vacation in this wonderful family home, enjoying the lively and intimate atmosphere while enjoying views of the town and its surrounding natural beauty. Bond over a book or the board games you’ve brought along. During cold seasons, bundle up together while enjoying the warmth of the fireplace.
The kitchen is stocked with cookware and cutlery, so you’ll have everything you’ll need for preparing dinner. There’s also a gas-powered grill near the pool, so you can hold a cookout if you’re craving steaks, hotdogs, and burgers.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
the house was well laid out and the backyard allowed for relaxing afternoons by the poolbeautiful home w great yard and pool areaand the yard was great we used the pool every dayCleanliness:
her house was so clean and comfortable as well as spaciouscomfortable and clean and so close to everything montauk loved our stayRead more reviewsHost:
she was attentive and kindshe was available helpful and accommodatingshe was extremely responsive to any questions i had from pre-booking right through the end of our stay
7. Extravagant oceanfront property (from USD 15000)
A holiday mansion through and through, this amazing home includes lavish features such as a home theater system, a double-height living room with plenty of windows, and a private section of the beach, complete with a walkway.
Let the chef of the group rule the kitchen like their own kingdom - the hi-tech appliances will let them work their magic. If you need to get some work done or are looking for a quiet place for afternoon drinks, the office might actually work well. The outdoor patio deck has tables and seating for everyone as well, so you can have a starlit evening dinner while admiring the sunset.
Top guest reviews
Read more reviewsLocation:
great location near montauk shops and restaurantsgreat location near montauk shops and restaurantsan amazing experience a beautiful location a wonderful spot
8. Stately and energy-efficient family home run by solar panels (from USD 857)
If you see yourself as environmentally conscious, you might want to check out this rental mansion that runs purely on solar power.
The open-plan living area has a tall vaulted ceiling, helping with the house’s circulation of air. The kitchen area itself has a slightly rustic aesthetic, perfectly in line with the rest of the home’s design. While there is no swimming pool, you can enjoy plenty of greenery around the yard. Enjoy a night under the stars at the second-floor balcony’s outdoor dining table, hopefully with wine and candlelight as well.
Top guest reviews
Cleanliness:
everything is practically brand new and immaculately cleanvery clean fully updated with nice decor and great hostHost:
beautiful house property and wonderful hostsRead more reviewsLocation:
the house is in a great location one mile from town (15-20 mina really terrific house in a quiet ideal location in montaukbeautiful home great quiet location
9. Large and spacious rental mansion with basement (from USD 1077)
Using a reverse floor plan, you can enjoy great views of the surroundings because the common areas such as the living room and deck are on the second floor of the house. Kick back with a tall glass in hand, relaxing on the deck’s loungers while the New York sunset dyes the sky a beautiful purple. For an equally enjoyable dining experience, you can keep warm by having a crackling fireplace lit up while everyone digs in.
As the bedrooms are on the first floor, you’ll be able to easily step outside first thing in the morning and get a lungful of crisp fresh air to energize yourself.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
great space plenty of room for a larger family gathering and excellent kitchen and dining areaHost:
greg was attentive and responsive throughoutwonderful house and greg was a great hostgreg was an excellent host and the property is spectaculargreg is also super responsive and helpfulgregory was very responsiveRead more reviewsLocation:
great location in montaukspectacular house and great locationoutstanding place and close to all activitiesstill would recommend giving this location a tryawesome location and great house with plenty of room
Superhost
10. Idyllic home right by the sea (from USD 2052)
You’ll feel like you’ve stepped onto a movie set when you book this gorgeous seaside home. Everything about it is picturesque, from the house’s classic look to the wild grass and trees growing around to form a trail that ushers you to the beach. There’s even a fire pit with seating, so you can watch the sunrise or sunset together as a group or family.
Back inside, you can enjoy sleeping in large spacious bedrooms, some with a balcony looking out to the lake. There’s even an office area with computers if you need to get some work done, even if it is your vacation.
Top guest reviews
Host:
lauren is a sweet hosthost was highly responsive and very easy to deal withshe was responsive helpful and gave my family and i a great vacationRead more reviewsLocation:
fantastic location and beautiful housefabulous location decorated wonderfully extremely comfortable home …
Montauk is a modern seaside paradise
The waters around Montauk exude an adventurous old-world charm that calls out to aspiring sportspersons and would-be adventurers. If this resonates with you as well, don’t forget to book any of these top mansion rentals in Montauk, New York, for your next trip.
History
Get Trip101 in your inbox
Unsubscribe in one click. See our Privacy Policy for more information on how we use your data
Create an account to