Old Forge, New York, was formerly the site of an iron mine, back in 1811. Old Forge was once a village, but it dissolved its incorporation in 1936. It remains the principal community of the region and, with its simple beauty, Old Forge has become a popular destination for many tourists. People also move to Old Forge because of its successful business district, which bursts with opportunities for those who actually seek them. Planning on visiting the city with your fur babies? There are stunning pet-friendly cabins and motels in and near Old Forge, New York, for you to have a fabulous holiday with your pets. If you are traveling with family, you can also choose from an array of beautiful Airbnb vacation rentals. Here’s a list of the best places to stay in Old Forge, New York, USA.
We handpicked these listings carefully, considering (wherever possible) Superhost status, recent guest reviews, location, accommodation type, prices, availability of dates, decor, and amenities. The image galleries get refreshed with the latest updates regularly. They were last updated on April 08, 2024.
1. Spacious holiday home near McCauley Mountain (from USD 199)
If you are wondering where to stay in Old Forge, New York, then worry no more. This deluxe holiday rental is located on the second floor of a quaint building. The comfy queen-sized beds can accommodate as many as six people. Bath towels and bed linen can be arranged at an additional cost.
The air-conditioned spaces also come with sufficient heating to ensure comfortable stays all year round. You can curl up with a book in front of the indoor fireplace should you decide to stay in. There is a laundromat nearby for washing needs. This rental comes equipped with free Wi-Fi which lets you work remotely if needed. For guests who love to cook, there is a fully-functional kitchen for meal preparations. Free car parking facilities are available onsite.
McCauley Mountain Ski & Bike Center is nearby and can be kept in your itinerary for sightseeing.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
chloe’s apartment is beautiful the beds were super comfyCleanliness:
very clean recent remodelvery clean and in good shapethe apartment was very clean and spaciousdespite being pet-friendly it was spotless and thoroughly cleanthe apartment was very clean and very niceHost:
she was unbelievably responsivechloe was a great hostchloe was the perfect hosthost was very communicative and friendlychloe was a great host and very responsiveRead more reviewsLocation:
the location is great - right in town and close to all the shops and restaurantscentral location parking dining just perfectenchanted forest is also very closewe could easily walk wherever we wanted in townpet friendly perfect central location in old forge
Superhost
2. Modern accommodation with free car parking
Located minutes away from the cool and Instagrammable spots, you will find this cozy accommodation nestled in a quiet neighborhood. An ideal choice for backpackers, families, and couples on a romantic holiday, this rental sleeps six people. A bathtub is provided for a leisurely shower after a long day.
The living area is done up with exquisite hardwood flooring and brick walls that lend character to the place. There is a coffee maker parked in the well-equipped kitchen for your daily dose of caffeine. If you are visiting in a car, you can have it parked on the premises for free.
Kids will have a blast in the nearby Enchanted Forest Water Safari amusement park. Moose River and McCauley Mountain are a stone’s throw away, and plenty of fun activities such as kayaking, canoeing, rafting, mountain biking, and snowmobiling can be done here.
Old Forge, New York, United States
1.91 km (1.2 mi) from Adirondack RailroadAccommodates: 6
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
there was one single fan on in one bedroomwe enjoyed the proximity to town the air conditioner in the living area and private parkingCleanliness:
it was clean and had a cabin vibethe mill cabin is a nice clean cozy cabin in an outstanding locationthere house is really cute and cleanHost:
the hosts were great easy to work with and answered my questions via text within a few hoursthe hostess contact was great and very responsiveRead more reviewsLocation:
great location in a nice quiet areaexcellent location and perfect size for our needsgreat spot centrally located friendly people quietthe location was perfect and having the house made the weekend that much betteryou can easily walk to the grocery store the liquor store the ice cream stand
3. Country Club Motel (from USD 99)
This motel is just a few kilometers away from the exciting locations of Old Forge, New York, such as the Enchanted Forest Water Safari. This makes this motel a super convenient place to stay. The clean and functional rooms are top-notch and guests love the superb service that the staff give. There’s also a swimming pool, where guests can read a book and soak up the sun or take an hour to swim and just enjoy a grand time. Guests also say that this property is perfect for couples.
Also See: 12 Fun things to do in Old Forge in 2020
Country Club Motel
Address: 2747 State Route 28
954 meters (0.6 ft) from Adirondack Railroad
4. Clark's Beach Motel (from USD 205)
Another perfect place to see the local beach of Old Forge is Clark’s Beach Motel. This simple yet cozy hotel is a favorite among tourists because of its location. Aside from being near the beach, Clark’s Beach Motel is also in the vicinity of the Enchanted Forest Water Safari. The accommodation provides an indoor pool, free Wi-Fi throughout the property and family rooms, making it perfect for families and friends. The beautiful view of the beach, plus the friendly staff, is enough to make any tourist long to stay here.
Clark's Beach Motel
Address: 3124 State Route - 28
3.13 km (2.0 mi) from Adirondack Railroad
5. Cozy, one-bedroom flat in Old Forge, New York (from USD 109)
Want some privacy? Then renting an Airbnb might be the best option for you. This cozy, one-bedroom flat offers a good accommodation option for those who are simply looking for a place to stay and chill in Old Forge, New York. There’s a ski hill and snowmobile trail near this accommodation in Old Forge. It offers free Wi-Fi and parking if you are going to bring a car. The flat is also near restaurants and liquor stores, making it an ideal place for a one-night staycation.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
full specturn tv cable and good wifithe heater was effective and quiet in taking the chill out of the cool weatherthere was a slew of information on the coffee table to help further plan a day's activitiescomfortable bed and so quiet at nightthe apartment is comfortable and had everything we neededCleanliness:
the apartment is clean and comfortablethe apartment was clean and quietthe house was very clean and comfortablethe apartment was very clean and nice with everything we neededapartment is comfortable and cleanHost:
considerate hosts that are ready to answer questions and make recommendationsthe host was gracious responsive and helpfulron was very friendly and made us feel welcomehad a great time paul was a great hosthe was friendly and easy to reach for anything we neededRead more reviewsLocation:
excellent location withing walking distance to food and drinkthe location was perfect for us out of the way but within walking distance to everythinggreat place location is perfect will definitely be backnice location on the tobie trail for hiking & bikinggreat quiet location a couple of blocks off the main road
6. Stunning waterfront cabin (from USD 172)
The ultimate staycation is this: a beautifully built cabin in front of the ocean. This cabin is charming and perfect during sunset or sunrise. There are two bedrooms and a common area. But the main event is the balcony, overlooking the ocean. You can sit on the balcony with your cup of coffee and take in the sunrise, just enjoying your vacation. Or, you can have a mini party with your friends that you brought with you for your Old Forge adventure. It’s also near the hiking trails and camping spots, perfect for adventurers.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
wonderful spot we loved eating breakfast on the deck would happily stay againthis camp is small and cozy with wonderful views of 1st lake in old forgethe kitchen and living room was one big room to enjoy visiting and games while preparing mealsCleanliness:
clean & beautiful locationrichard’s place was great it was clean and cozythe shower in the shed was clean and dry (i'm used to camping)this is a great clean little cabin with the most amazing viewsuper clean and family friendly richard is a great hostRead more reviewsLocation:
fantastic location for all your adk adventuresthe location was perfect right across from first lakegreat location i am picky about beds but the queen bed was greatgreat place to stay in old forge
7. Rustic, three-bedroom bungalow (from USD 150)
Bringing a lot of friends on your trip? This three-bedroom stunner is perfect for groups of up to eight people. The spacious property has three bedrooms – all of them are large and have up to two beds each. The bungalow is charming with its white exterior. Inside, the wooden walls and floors look amazing during the winter when it’s freezing outside and you’re surrounded with amazing coziness.
There’s also a balcony and backyard outside, perfect for barbeques and late-night parties. The Moose River is also nearby for boating, photo shoots and other adventures that you and your group would want to do.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
just wish had some air conditioninghad a wonderful stay and enjoyed the view from the dining room sliderwhat a great place we loved the adirondack décor (the living room couch was beautiful )the house was perfect for our family with lots of beds for everyoneit was very comfortable and homey and had everything we neededCleanliness:
clean and comfortablebeds were super clean and comfythe place is very cleanvery clean place and ample space inside homethe place was very clean and had everything you neededHost:
the host is very responsive toogreat response times from the hosts and were flexible with our check in timehost was very accommodating and easy to communicate withcharlene was the best host we have ever had she went above and beyond to make her stay comfortablethis was helpful since i left from work and was arriving lateRead more reviewsLocation:
the location is greatexcellent location right in townthe location was perfectfantastic location in old forgeeasy walk into the village
8. Quiet Old Forge getaway (from USD 285)
There are tons of cabins in Old Forge, but this one is one of the most gorgeous. The rustic, all-wood design is perfect for cozy winter nights with the fireplace and a nice cup of coffee in hand. There are three bedrooms and each one of them is cute and large. The cabin, which is perfect for up to six guests, is just a few minutes away from the gorgeous Fulton Lakes. Guests will also have access to a washer, dryer and BBQ grill, as well as a full kitchen with dishwasher, fridge and freezer, two decks, a grill and a firepit.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
lots of space comfortable bedsCleanliness:
extremely clean and organize housethis place is very clean and comfortablevery clean lots of adk memorabilia and tokens to get in the great outdoors moodexcellent location and very clean housevery clean beautiful home our family was very impressed and happy with our stayHost:
christopher and kathy were amazing they were so helpful and responsive to questionschristopher and his mom kathy were not only accommodating but great hostwe had an excellent stay everyone was very friendlyRead more reviewsLocation:
the location was perfect for our eventgreat location and great house definitely recommend to othersa beautiful place to stay in a great locationclose enough to the village of old forge to enjoy all that old forge has to offerspacious comfortable home nestled in the woods close to downtown old forge
9. Spacious Old Forge cabin
“Airy” is one word that can describe this property. This spacious cabin can accommodate up to eight guests and is owned by a verified Superhost. There is a front deck with a picnic table and gas grill and a small firepit next to the garage, which means the whole gang can chill and have backyard parties on the lawn. It’s also near the lakes and other exciting nature trails that Old Forge has to offer. Book this property for a functional yet comfortable trip in Old Forge.
Old Forge, New York, United States
7.42 km (4.7 mi) from Adirondack RailroadAccommodates: 8
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
the free wifi was high speed so it never slowed down once with any of our devicesthe shower had great pressure and never ran out of hot waterthe tv also came with all the great apps such as netflix and huluinside has a good sized living room with a tv and access to appsi personally loved the farm door on the bathroom cabinetCleanliness:
very clean and well stockedvery clean and well keptthe cabin was clean neat and invitingthe place was clean easy to find and close to townHost:
host is extremely responsiveanother phenomenal thing about her home is that is very kid friendlyRead more reviewsLocation:
the location was perfectnice quiet street close to everythinggreat house with a wonderful location only a few miles away from town would definitely rent againthe location was close to town and on a nice quiet streetit was close to town about 3 miles to enchanted forrest water safari
10. Pine Knoll Lodge & Cabins, Inc. (from USD 198)
Pine Knoll Lodge & Cabins, Inc. is perfect in both summer and winter. In the winter, the water in front of the hotel freezes, giving you a breathtaking winter view like no other. During the summer, this body of water becomes its friendly self - perfect for boat riding and other water-related activities. The rooms are cozy and the beds are all decorated with the best blankets and pillows, ensuring that your staycation will be nothing but wonderful. The location is excellent since it’s near the town and the other attractions Old Forge can offer.
Pine Knoll Hotel Lakeside Lodge & Cabin
Address: 123 South Shore Road PO Box 1130
3.04 km (1.9 mi) from Adirondack Railroad
11. Stunning lake house with mini outdoor hot tub
This stunning lake house is a great deal for your money. It can accommodate up to 15 people with its spacious five bedrooms. The view is just amazing, with the lake surrounding the property. There’s also a hot tub sitting in front of the lake. You can end your day with a wine in hand, relaxing in the hot tub, simply enjoying what Old Forge has to offer. There are three full baths and the property is located near the best adventures the town can offer.
Old Forge, New York, United States
6.93 km (4.4 mi) from Adirondack RailroadTop guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
it's beautiful has great views awesome taxidermy animals relatively close to town very warm and cozythe house is a beautiful adk log cabin with plenty of room to accommodate a big groupRead more reviewsLocation:
jeffs house is in a beautiful location and the house is awesomethis cabin is a beautiful and spacious home in a perfect location
Stunning hotels and cabins in Old Forge, New York
You can enjoy the best of the quaint and beautiful through these accommodations and hotels in and near Old Forge, New York. Plan your trip to the city by booking one of these top places, and expect exciting adventures ahead!
History
Get Trip101 in your inbox
Unsubscribe in one click. See our Privacy Policy for more information on how we use your data
Create an account to