The central region of the New York State features a total of 11 long and narrow water bodies. Looking at them together from the aerial perspective, they appear as fingers on a hand. In reality, this geography was carved by the glacier activities some million years ago, and now we get to see mountains, waterfalls, and many such scenic views. Tourism is active year-round, and there are numerous hotel accommodations in nearby villages, but we are presenting you something even closer to those lakes. The rental options on our list will help you choose the best accommodation for your needs. Continue this read if you’re interested in knowing about the best Vrbo accommodations near Finger Lakes, New York.
We handpicked these listings carefully, considering (wherever possible) Superhost status, recent guest reviews, location, accommodation type, prices, availability of dates, decor, and amenities. The image galleries get refreshed with the latest updates regularly. They were last updated on August 31, 2025.
1. Estate built with a Victorian gazebo (from USD 552)
This property is located in Trumansburg village, thus the nearest Finger Lake is Cayuga. The tariff and the pictures shown here denotes just the main house on the estate land, which can accommodate up to 12 guests in total. The house comprises four bedrooms, plus two and a half bathrooms. They provide Wifi, cable television, a DVD player, books and games. Along with that, there is a swimming pool, whirlpool spa, outdoor grill, a lawn, and patio under a Victorian gazebo, which was built here in the year 1852. Please be advised that the swimming area could be shared with the cottage renters if they arrive with you. Having smaller celebrations will be free here, but a gathering of 20+ person would require a fee.
Trumansburg, New York, United States
31.94 km (19.9 mi) from The Windmill Farm & Craft Market
Top guest reviews
Host:
owners were super easy to work withchris and christine the owners were helpful and eager to please usthe owner christine was very responsive to any query i hadthank you christine for hosting my families reunion with four of our daughters that live across the countryLocation:
we really liked the location which was in trumansburg and within walking distance of downtowna perfect location to visit and enjoy what the finger lakes have to offerlocation of the property was also excellent with easy access to the lake hiking food shopping wineries etcthe location is very convenient in downtown trumansburg but it feels like you are out in the countryt'berg is a great location for visiting the wineries and state parks on both large lakesCleanliness:
very clean throughout and comfortable bedsclean clean clean with lovely furnishings and a welcoming vibewe were richly rewarded with a wonderful house that was warm spacious clean and beautifulthe home was neat and clean and had a well equipped kitchenRead more reviewsAmenities & Room:
and the sweet covered patio with grand tables and a grill centered our meals and social activitiesthe house is very inviting and the furniture is comfortablethe beds were very comfortable and the layout of the house allowed flexibility in our sleeping arrangementsthe pool was great for our grandchildren who ranged from age two months to 12 years oldthe pool and covered patio saved the day when the grandchildren came
2. Ideal cabin for a couple's stay (from USD 199)
This small cottage is intended for couples to stay in; they have forbidden kids here. There is one bedroom and one bathroom inside this house, but still, they throw in a lot more amenities than a hotel room with comparable tariff. This private cabin boasts a swimming pool, a hot tub, a garage with remote opening shutters, patio with grillers, and a wide lawn. Besides that, guests will have a satellite television, a DVD player, a book library, and board games. It’s located in Fayetteville Village near the Syracuse City, thus Onondaga and Oneida, both the Finger Lakes, are in close proximity.
Fayetteville, New York, United States
98.71 km (61.4 mi) from The Windmill Farm & Craft Market
Top guest reviews
Host:
arrival was pleasant and owners attention to personal detail was pleasinghosts were super welcoming & friendlyour hosts have set a high bar for home sharing! from the moment we arrived we felt welcome and comfortablewe had the most wonderful new years eve in recent memorywhen we arrived it was no different! she made us feel valued and welcomedLocation:
it is completely peaceful and secluded with beautiful gardenslocated in a quiet convenient neighborhood centrally locateddonna provided great recommendations for local restaurants and area sightswe desperately needed a get away from the holiday stress and donna delivered in a big way! from the beginning donna was there! immediately we felt at ease with her quick and friendly responses to o...my husband and i recently spent 4 nights at this great guesthouse complete with pool and hot tub- a very relaxing place to come back to each evening after exploring the area each dayCleanliness:
the space is immaculately kept and clean, and the homeowners couldn't be more pleasantthe guesthouse and grounds were immaculate and had everything we needed for a perfect stayRead more reviewsAmenities & Room:
cottage has everything you need to make it a wonderful, comfortable staywe needed ask for nothing as everything is stocked and available from pool towels to hairspray and toothbrushesdonna thought of everything from the fresh baked cookies, the blueberry stuffed french toast, the use of the garage, and the touches throughout the living space left no need unsatisfiedit was so much more inviting than a hotel room, and i took advantage of the hot tub a few nightssuch lovely people! the place had everything we needed and more!! we relaxed and enjoyed the hottub, sat out on the deck and had our breakfast, the bed was so comfy and the people were the icing on...
3. Wheelchair accessible lodging (from USD 341)
This is a lakefront property—Seneca Lake this time. The main building is wheelchair accessible and comprises two bedrooms plus one bathroom; the lodging capacity is for six adults. This cottage features separate televisions in the living room and bedroom, DVD and VCR player, stereo, Wifi, working Netflix plan and a physical video library, book library, and board games. In the backyard, there is a barbecue grill with roofed patio, a private dock, and boat rental close by. Your pets are allowed free of charge.
Romulus, New York, United States
24.04 km (15.0 mi) from The Windmill Farm & Craft Market
Top guest reviews
Host:
He was so gracious to our youngest son giving him bait and helping him with the row boatthe owner is a guide and knows what he's doingThe owner lives right next door and was extremely responsive to any need we hadWe cannot wait to return next yearJoe is a wonderful hostLocation:
We also ventured out to check out the 3 Brothers Brewery which was just a few miles from Joes placeIt is just a short drive to all the best restaurants wineries and breweries in the regionBeautiful views Close to good wineries and restaurants on Seneca Lake Perfect for a quick trip or longer stay if you want to enjoy lake activitiesWe enjoyed walking the dog and running at nearby Sampson and Seneca ParksWe also ventured out to check out the sites such as Corning Glassware Watkins Glen and Taughannock State ParkCleanliness:
The location can't be beatRead more reviewsAmenities & Room:
The cottage is so cozythe room with king size bed has no doorThere was nothing we needed that was not there in the cottageThe cabin has everything you need and the owners have everything looking greatHis cottage is right off the Seneca Lake
4. The best rental for a crowd (from USD 929)
After doing some basic math, a lakefront cottage accommodating 27 guests for such a low rental price seems just unreal, and surprisingly, they haven’t trimmed out the amenities. This rental comes with three televisions, two stereos, games, an Xbox console, a DVD player, library, toys, and Wifi. This bungalow is built on the banks of Waneta Lake and comprises eight bedrooms and four bathrooms. The backyard has a dock with a free canoe, kayak, and a rowboat. And in that same yard, you have an outdoor cooking area and a huge patio. Small celebrations and pets are permitted when their fee is paid.
Dundee, New York, United States
13.33 km (8.3 mi) from The Windmill Farm & Craft Market
Top guest reviews
Host:
The owner was very responsive and accommodatingThey were both filled with dirty water when we arrivedis well stocked Owner was great and brought extra air conditionerswas awesome Very nice family reunionold dirty and rickety andLocation:
We enjoyed direct access to Waneta Lake and the close proximity to Hammondsport and Watkins Glenbut we only used one after my son spent time cleaning it outThere is also a nice swimming and diving area for older children and adults Nice shops too in the small village for shopping and be sure to get some ice cream at the Crooked Lake Ice Cream ParlorThe dishwasher was operational but very hard to load the bottom rack if it was pulled out Repairs needed Other than that we loved the house and the locationhouse and lake are beautifulCleanliness:
By the end of the week the sulfur smell had started to dissipate and wasn't as noticeableRead more reviewsAmenities & Room:
The game room was a great space for the kids to playinstead we spent most of our time using the boats and fishing off the docksThere was plenty of hot water and we found the majority of the bedsWe didn't do anything on the lake due to the weatherThe kitchen is big enough to prepare meals for a large group and having multiple grills was also very helpful and appreciated The game room downstairs
5. Little wooden cabin
This little wooden cabin is located nearby Canandaigua Lake and also a skiing club. There is just one bedroom with two double beds, thus four people can sleep here. Besides that, one bathroom, and a half bath is also available. This cabin features satellite television with a working Netflix plan, Wifi, and lots of books. Although this cabin is small, they have a modern kitchen inside, and on the outside, there is a barbecue griller and patio. A swimming pool is also on site, but it’s not heated.
32.58 km (20.3 mi) from The Windmill Farm & Craft MarketAccommodates: 4
Minimum Nights: 2
Refund Policy : 100% refund if you cancel at least 60 days before check-in.
Top guest reviews
Host:
nice size pool Did not meet owners in person but with total experienceShe offered to gather some groceries for usThe pool was excellent and the home was extremely comfortable and the hosts were very accomodating including some nice treats for us first thing when we got thereyou can tell their awesome n very considerate couplehad a bottle of champagne waiting for us and even some lovely decorations in the bedroom to emphasize the new love that was coming into her homeLocation:
Wonderful property located in a beautiful areaCottage is right next to the main house though and the pool is right behind the main houseand we were even able to get a fire going and enjoy the night surrounded by nothing but the woods on their 14 acre propertyIt is so close to great restaurantsI highly recommend the little house if your looking for a peaceful relaxing place in a country setting but is close enough to places with things to doCleanliness:
The house had everything we needed and was very clean and well keptThis Little house was nice&clean and full of amenitiesThe little house had everything we needed and the owners take great care of the propertyIt was clean and has a well outfitted kitchenRead more reviewsAmenities & Room:
The house was immaculate with all of the amenitiesThe view of the large yard through its many windows was pleasant and comfortingEspecially the pool after a day of chasing a wedding in heelsThe pool was great in the warm August sun"The Little House was perfect Beautiful quiet updated amenities very comfortable Conveniently located to town and still feels like you have your own park
6. Upscale cottage on the banks of Seneca
We have another rental option on the banks of Seneca, but it’s upscale. This is a massive cedar wood chalet that comprises four bedrooms and three bathrooms. The sleeping arrangement is designed for eight guests. Some notable amenities with this cottage are two 32” televisions on the upper level, a 60” plasma television with surround speakers in the lower level, DVD players, a video library, a full-size pool table, and lots of toys. Besides that, there is an extended lawn, griller on the deck, a large patio with hot tub, dock with two kayaks, two canoes, and a rowboat. Smoking is allowed on this property, and pets are welcome upon paying charges.
1965 Perry Point Rd
13.39 km (8.4 mi) from The Windmill Farm & Craft Market
7. Farmhouse with sauna
This Victorian style farmhouse can accommodate more lodgers than our previous options; a total of 24 guests can stay here with ease. The cottage is located very close to Cayuga Lake and comprises ten bedrooms, seven bathrooms, and a half bath. They have a sauna, a hot tub, and a full-sized swimming pool, although it’s not heated. The indoor enjoyment is limited to a satellite television and Wifi this time, however, on the outside, you’ll see an extensive lawn, barbecue with patio, and seats around a fire pit. Lodging with pets is welcome without an extra charge.
37.91 km (23.6 mi) from The Windmill Farm & Craft MarketTop guest reviews
Host:
good central spaces for gathering Hosts were VERY attentive easy to contact and accommodatingLuckily the person who fell was 57The owners were always available to respond to any questions we hadpleasant and helpful Kids loved the poolPaula was great meeting us at the house and showing us the propertyLocation:
(we got delivery from Lansing Pizza one night)The group is interested in renting this house again in the summer timethe carriage house rooms were filled with spiders and had a real funky smell going on from the A/C the grounds of the property were beautiful the pool a little sketchyWe had a group of 12 celebrating the life of my momhowever there is a difference between old and degraded FewRead more reviewsAmenities & Room:
The house and the yard had loads of space and the kitchen was fully stocked with everything we neededThe house was stocked with everything we neededThe house was excellent and provided everything we neededIt was able to accommodate all of usAmple linens were provided for all the guests
8. Chalet nearby a ski resort
This cottage is slightly smaller than the previous two, but can comfortably lodge 22 adults. The two-story high chalet has five bedrooms, three bathrooms, and a half bath. Canandaigua Lake is nearby, and Bristol Mountain Ski Resort is just about one kilometer (0.6 mi) away. A separate satellite television is mounted in the living room, and Wifi is also available. Here as well, you will notice a heated pool, hot tub, outside griller, and patio. The primary renter has to be 25 or older to book this place, and parties are allowed with permission and an extra fee.
South Bristol, NY, US
33.67 km (21.0 mi) from The Windmill Farm & Craft MarketTop guest reviews
Host:
jill the manager is very pleasant and helpfulRead more reviewsCleanliness:
this property is clean well furnished and perfect for large groupsthe place was very clean and stocked well with plenty to make cooking for a large group easy
9. Cedar wood cottage near Hemlock
This cedar wood rental is massive. Upon exploring its upstairs, downstairs, and the basement layout, you’ll find six bedrooms and four full, plus a half bath. The bed plan can accommodate 20 adults. The cottage features a game room that has game tables and video games. Two extra televisions are fixed in a different area, and Wifi is available too. The location is nearby Hemlock Lake; Conesus is also not very far. The prime renter should be at least 26 years old for this booking, and private parties are allowed if you can pay extra. The place has a heated pool, a hot tub, and outdoor grill with patio.
Wayland, New York, United States
45.59 km (28.4 mi) from The Windmill Farm & Craft Market
Top guest reviews
Host:
Everyone loved the game room too Diane and Jill were also so kind and easy to work withJill was a wonderful hostso I had to hand change thoseWebster Properties was always clear in communication and followed throughThey had it changed in the house bookLocation:
They were located at a great distance from each each not too farThe Lodge lived up to it's reputation and moreWe loved sitting by the fire at night tooOur plans were to get married on the dock and have the reception around the poolWe rented both properties since we had 5 families and my parentsCleanliness:
The bedrooms and bathrooms were spacious and cleanUnfortunately the weather didn't cooperateRead more reviewsAmenities & Room:
There was ample room and the photos in front of the gorgeous fireplace are outstandingthe decking needs to be re stainedThe sprawling space of the Lodge gave us the space we needed to be able to spread outThe kitchen was very well equipped as was the outdoor cooking areakitchen fridge was on the small side
10. Lakeview cottage at a private estate
Another cottage, but with a lake view, as it’s built right next to Canadice Lake. Along with the cabin, guests are also given access to acres of private estate land. The main house has five bedrooms and four bathrooms; up to 18 people can sleep here comfortably. The minimum age of the primary renter is 25 for this booking, and event reservations require a larger tariff. This cottage also boasts a gaming area and a dedicated television for video games. Besides that, two extra satellite televisions, a stereo, and Wifi are provided. This chalet also comes with a heated pool, hot tub, barbecue, and patio.
Springwater, NY, US
45.4 km (28.3 mi) from The Windmill Farm & Craft MarketTop guest reviews
Host:
jill was helpful throughout the booking process ensuring we had all our questions answered ahead of timeLocation:
restaurants are at least 15 minutes away as is closest grocery store (honeoye shur fine is pretty good)this place is a perfect family getawayCleanliness:
comfortable property clean and fully equippedthe lodge was very clean and well stocked with everything one would need to start a memorable holidaythe house was easy to locate clean spacious and had ample bedrooms and seatingRead more reviewsAmenities & Room:
excellent amenities such as heated pool hot tub game room outdoor dining areasthe house is well organized spotless and has lots of amenities to make you comfortable
Don’t forget to visit the Grand Canyon of the East
We agree that the lakes are splendid, and you will be spending much of your holidays exploring the 11 Finger Lakes. But wait! Do not leave this part of New York without visiting the Letchworth State Park. It’s only a few kilometers away from the lakes, and upon visiting this park, you will know why they say it is The Grand Canyon of the East.
History
Get Trip101 in your inbox
Unsubscribe in one click. See our Privacy Policy for more information on how we use your data