Sanibel Island is the new “it” destination in Florida. Located close to Fort Myers, its golden sunsets, quaint atmosphere, and laid-back vibe are steadily gaining fans from all over. And when they get to Sanibel Island, a lot of activities await: sunbathing at Bowman’s Beach, kayaking at Great Calusa Causeway, hiking at paddling at J.N. Ding Darling National Wildlife Refuge, and checking out the exotic local produce at Sanibel Farmers Market, among many other things.
All these activities are a short bike ride from these top resorts on Sanibel Island, Florida. Continue reading to find out why we highly recommend these retreats.
We handpicked these listings carefully, considering (wherever possible) Superhost status, recent guest reviews, location, accommodation type, prices, availability of dates, decor, and amenities. The image galleries get refreshed with the latest updates regularly. They were last updated on October 23, 2025.
Other accommodations on Sanibel Island, Florida
1. Sundial Beach Resort and Spa (from USD 438)
A short walk or bike-ride away from Sanibel Island’s Periwinkle Way is Sundial Beach Resort and Spa. This chic and contemporary accommodation offers a full-service spa, five different swimming pools (you’ll never worry about crowded pools here), tennis courts, and access to a long stretch of beach. If you fancy playing golf, there is one next door.
What sets Sundial apart is its collection of on-site restaurants. There are five dining options located within the resort, featuring interesting and diverse dishes such as sushi and steaks.
Sundial Beach Resort & Spa
Address: 1451 Middle Gulf Drive
10.85 km (6.8 mi) from Bowman's Beach
2. Island Inn (from USD 219)
Island Inn takes you back to the late 19th century with its plantation-inspired buildings with a tropical twist. This is the oldest resort on the island and has been serving patrons since 1895. They keep coming back for the island’s stretch of white beach, one- to three-bedroom cottages, and seafood restaurants.
Other hotel amenities include tennis courts, a heated outdoor pool, and barbecue stations for grilling. Bike and kayak rentals are also available if you wish to explore the area on land or water.
Island Inn
Address: 3111 West Gulf Drive
7.07 km (4.4 mi) from Bowman's Beach
3. Sanibel Island Beach Resort (from USD 234)
Sanibel Island Beach Resort is the epitome of Old Florida charm with its laid-back approach to vacationing. Wide swathes of empty beach and hammocks swaying in the wind will put your mind at ease here. The entire resort is pet- and eco-friendly as well, so you’ll be close to nature.
Rooms and suites at the resort offer stunning views of the gardens or the beach. As for on-site perks, count two restaurants, shelling beaches, outdoor pools, and bike rentals among others.
Sanibel Island Beach Resort
Address: 1231 Middle Gulf Drive
11.27 km (7.1 mi) from Bowman's Beach
4. Seahorse Cottages
Proximity to local cafes and grocery stores for dining and provisions.
Reasonable rates for newly remodeled cottages near Lighthouse Beach.
Conveniently located near Lighthouse Beach, shops, and dining options.
Complimentary bikes, beach supplies, and cozy, clean cottages with front and back patios.
If you want a truly tranquil getaway on Sanibel Island, consider Seahorse Cottages. This small beachfront resort is exclusively for adult use, guaranteeing privacy and serenity. Cottages range from studio setups to two-bedroom accommodations, complete with kitchenettes, living and dining, and private decks. Rent a bike to explore the neighborhood and go shopping at Old Town Sanibel.
Seahorse Cottages - Adults Only
Address: 1223 Buttonwood Lane
13.27 km (8.3 mi) from Bowman's Beach
One of Florida's underrated destinations
For your upcoming trip, skip Miami, Orlando, and Fort Myers, and opt for the underrated but no less than an attractive destination in Florida, Sanibel Island. You’ll find similar places, plus top resorts and the best things to do when you check out the endless collection of travel guides that we share.
History
Get Trip101 in your inbox
Unsubscribe in one click. See our Privacy Policy for more information on how we use your data