10 Best Vacation Rentals With Private Pool In Finger Lakes, New York - Updated 2024

Shamika
Shamika 
Updated
| 4 min read

From world-famous wineries and breweries that line the city streets to the breathtaking natural beauty of the lakefront, it is no wonder that Finger Lakes region attracts thousands of travellers from all over the country every year. If you are interested in outdoor activities, you can enjoy hiking in the various state parks or try kayaking and paddleboarding in the lakes. Looking for a more relaxing experience? Try one of the lake cruises here or enjoy the popular Canandaigua Lake Wine Trail or other tours at Billsboro Winery or Arbor Hill Grapery & Winery. You can end your day with a waterfront dinner at New York Kitchen. Lastly, treat yourself to an accommodation with a pool where you can relax in style. Read on to explore the best vacation rentals with private pool in Finger Lakes, New York.

We handpicked these listings carefully, considering (wherever possible) host status, recent guest reviews, location, accommodation type, prices, availability of dates, decor, and access to private pool. The image galleries get refreshed with the latest updates regularly. They were last updated on March 11, 2024.

1. Charming and aesthetic four-bedroom home (from USD 825)

Featuring a luxurious in-ground heated pool (open from mid-May to the beginning of October), this amazing home is aesthetically pleasing with neutral tones used throughout the space. It overlooks a large lake and offers incredible views of the surrounding meadows and woodlands. The home features a sprawling open-concept kitchen, living and dining area with vaulted ceilings and large windows allowing natural light.

You can also enjoy a basement bar area with a flat-screen television, play games on the lawn or take the four kayaks out on the lake.

Stayed at this property?
21 reviews  
House 14 Guests 4 Bedrooms 3 Bathrooms

Accommodates: 14
Minimum Nights: 1
Refund Policy : 100% refund if you cancel at least 60 days before check-in.

Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
loved that the house was stocked with board games and the kitchen is well appointed
Cleanliness:
the property was excellent very clean and perfect for a relaxing weekend away
overall the property was good clean and in a great location
Host:
property manager was super responsive
the property manager was amazing and super responsive
joleen the hostess was very responsive and answered any of our questions
Location:
terrific location between ithaca and seneca falls
it was a great place to stay right on the lake
it is our favorite place to stay in the finger lakes
the property was in a wonderful location we didn't leave the property the entire weekend
Read more reviews
Earn OneKeyCash for every dollar spent on eligible hotels, vacation rentals, flights, car rentals, and more when you book across our family of brands.

2. Modern farmhouse with contemporary amenities (from USD 1200)

This farmhouse consists of all the modern conveniences and luxuries that you deserve in a private vacation home. Set on acres of private property with well-manicured lawns, this home offers an in-ground pool for the hot summer months, a luxurious chef’s kitchen to prepare delicious homemade meals, and a gas fire pit where you can roast marshmallows. The home also boasts fast WiFi for remote workers and is pet-friendly, making it perfect for families with dogs.

Stayed at this property?
30 reviews   Wifi Available
House 16 Guests 6 Bedrooms 4 Bathrooms

Accommodates: 16
Minimum Nights: 3
Refund Policy : 100% refund if you cancel at least 60 days before check-in.

Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
the patio and pool kept the children engaged and the lake was nearby
this house was absolutely gorgeous and had more than enough room/space for our 15 person group
the pool and yard is beautiful
Cleanliness:
very clean and very well-stocked
when we arrived the house was spotlessly clean
the house and property were clean as a whistle
Host:
alan was an incredible host and was very accommodating and responsive
the owner was extremely responsive and everything was just perfect
property was amazing and the hosts were extremely responsive
where to start… the whole experience with the property owner and property was fantastic
it's truly a special place and alan was very attentive to our needs
Location:
great location beautiful and very unique home and setting
Read more reviews
Earn OneKeyCash for every dollar spent on eligible hotels, vacation rentals, flights, car rentals, and more when you book across our family of brands.

3. Sprawling lakefront home with five bedrooms (from USD 539)

Situated in a quiet cul-de-sac on a paved road, this beautiful and sprawling home is perfect for large families or groups as it features 5 bedrooms and can accommodate up to 12 guests. The home also boasts a large private pool that is open from mid-May to mid-September, so you can chill out in the hot summer months.

In addition, the home also has a chef’s kitchen where you can prepare delicacies for your loved ones, a private patio with a barbecue grill and outdoor seating, and Wi-Fi.

Stayed at this property?
Ovid, New York, United States
PRIVATE VACATION HOME 12 Guests 5 Bedrooms 4 Bathrooms

Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
the rooms were spacious and fit all of us comfortably we had space to gather and for privacy
we especially enjoyed the pool area and the outside space at the dock
the grandkids spent most of the week in the pool especially enjoying the slide and diving board
the house is comfortable and big
Cleanliness:
jill's property was very clean and well kept
the house is spacious clean and homey
the pool was lovely--warm and clean
everything was as described clean and the place was very roomy
the house was extremely clean quiet and well-stocked with everything that you may need
Host:
the owners were very responsive to any questions as well
owners were responsive to questions/requests both before and during our stay
jill is easy to work with and responsive
Location:
everyone loved the house the location and all the close breweries
the kitchen set up is outstanding we could not have been happier with this location and the house
Read more reviews
Earn OneKeyCash for every dollar spent on eligible hotels, vacation rentals, flights, car rentals, and more when you book across our family of brands.

4. Luxurious six-bedroom log cabin (from USD 800)

Featuring six sprawling bedrooms and a log cabin vibe throughout the space, this luxury home is built completely out of wood and combines the country with the contemporary. The home is located on several acres of private property. It can accommodate up to 20 guests, and it even hosts special events such as weddings and other parties (separate rates). It features a private pool, a relaxing hot tub and a cosy fireplace, making it a great year-round choice.

Stayed at this property?
25 reviews   Wifi Available
lodge 14 Guests 6 Bedrooms 5 Bathrooms

Accommodates: 14
Minimum Nights: 2
Refund Policy : 100% refund if you cancel at least 60 days before check-in.

Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
There was ample room and the photos in front of the gorgeous fireplace are outstanding
the decking needs to be re stained
The sprawling space of the Lodge gave us the space we needed to be able to spread out
The kitchen was very well equipped as was the outdoor cooking area
kitchen fridge was on the small side
Cleanliness:
The bedrooms and bathrooms were spacious and clean
Unfortunately the weather didn't cooperate
Host:
Everyone loved the game room too Diane and Jill were also so kind and easy to work with
Jill was a wonderful host
so I had to hand change those
Webster Properties was always clear in communication and followed through
They had it changed in the house book
Location:
They were located at a great distance from each each not too far
The Lodge lived up to it's reputation and more
We loved sitting by the fire at night too
Our plans were to get married on the dock and have the reception around the pool
We rented both properties since we had 5 families and my parents
Read more reviews
Earn OneKeyCash for every dollar spent on eligible hotels, vacation rentals, flights, car rentals, and more when you book across our family of brands.

5. Luxurious four-bedroom home on a private estate (from USD 650)

If you wish to take your vacation to the next level, why not book this luxurious and historic property that is a landmark in Finger Lakes? The property has well-manicured, sprawling gardens with lawn chairs for al fresco dining as well as a private patio ideal for barbecue parties and picnicking. With a large pool to slip into when the weather gets too hot, you are sure to have an amazing time here.

Stayed at this property?
Trumansburg, New York, United States
PRIVATE VACATION HOME 12 Guests 4 Bedrooms 3 Bathrooms

Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
and the sweet covered patio with grand tables and a grill centered our meals and social activities
the house is very inviting and the furniture is comfortable
the beds were very comfortable and the layout of the house allowed flexibility in our sleeping arrangements
the pool was great for our grandchildren who ranged from age two months to 12 years old
the pool and covered patio saved the day when the grandchildren came
Cleanliness:
very clean throughout and comfortable beds
clean clean clean with lovely furnishings and a welcoming vibe
we were richly rewarded with a wonderful house that was warm spacious clean and beautiful
the home was neat and clean and had a well equipped kitchen
Host:
owners were super easy to work with
chris and christine the owners were helpful and eager to please us
the owner christine was very responsive to any query i had
thank you christine for hosting my families reunion with four of our daughters that live across the country
Location:
we really liked the location which was in trumansburg and within walking distance of downtown
a perfect location to visit and enjoy what the finger lakes have to offer
location of the property was also excellent with easy access to the lake hiking food shopping wineries etc
the location is very convenient in downtown trumansburg but it feels like you are out in the country
t'berg is a great location for visiting the wineries and state parks on both large lakes
Read more reviews
Earn OneKeyCash for every dollar spent on eligible hotels, vacation rentals, flights, car rentals, and more when you book across our family of brands.

6. Contemporary three-bedroom house with a private pool (from USD 250)

Featuring a variety of amenities designed to make your vacation experience truly unforgettable, this three-bedroom home is ideal for a family or a group of friends and can comfortably accommodate up to 12 guests. It has a home theatre with recliners for fun movie nights, an in-ground private pool, a foosball table and multiple walking trails starting right from your backyard.

Stayed at this property?
Lima, New York, United States
114 reviews   Superhost Wifi Available
ENTIRE HOME 7 Beds 10 Guests 3 Bedrooms 2 Bathrooms

Accommodates: 10

Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
we had an awesome time in the pool and we cooked out on the grill
the boys loved the theater room and bunkbeds
we enjoyed the theater room and had more than enough room for all of us
Cleanliness:
place is tidy and clean
everything was clean the house smelled good and the rooms were comfy thanks for a great place
very affordable clean and all necessities are readily available
the house felt fresh and clean and the beds and pillows were very comfortable
Host:
traci is an excellent and efficient host
she was very responsive and met all of our needs
such a great stay host put in great effort into ensuring that the property was super comfortable and hospitable
Location:
beautiful home nestled in a nice quiet neighborhood in the finger lakes region
the trails behind the house were so picturesque and neighborhood kind with people walking dogs and kids playing
Read more reviews

7. Spacious six-bedroom home with a heated pool (from USD 595)

Situated in Skaneateles in the Finger Lakes, this spacious home is perfect for a relaxing vacation with majestic views. It features a spacious heated pool (open May 15 to October 15) complete with poolside loungers, a large deck, a fully equipped kitchen and a children’s playroom.

Additionally, guests are welcome to enjoy fresh garden harvests and wild black raspberries.

Stayed at this property?
Skaneateles, New York, United States
53 reviews   Wifi Available
ENTIRE HOME 8 Beds 12 Guests 6 Bedrooms 3 Bathrooms

Accommodates: 12

Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
great views lots of space and kitchen amenities
everything you need along with beautiful views of the lake it was peaceful and so comfortable
house is secluded and quiet with a spectacular lake view pool and hot tub a bonus
Cleanliness:
very clean and accommodated 8 of us very easily
check in was a breeze and the house was clean and as advertised when we arrived
the house was just “as advertised ” lovely spacious and welcoming
Host:
the hosts are thorough and thoughtful
thank you for being wonderful hosts and sharing your home
they were perfect hosts for our annual get together with all the grands
gillian and ayham were fantastic hosts and were very communicative and accommodating
gillian and ayham are wonderful hosts and we loved our stay
Location:
the house is in a great location to the town center
view and sunset was great downtown skaneateles is close by
amazing view great location wonderful home for a large family
Read more reviews

8. Stylish five-bedroom home perfect for large groups

This lovely five-bedroom home can accommodate up to 18 guests, making it a great choice for large families or groups. The home features amazing amenities such as a huge gaming room with a flatscreen television and videogames, a fenced-in pool (open during summer), a hot tub (open year-round) to slip into after a long day and an outdoor barbecue on the patio.

For relaxation with some privacy, you can soak in the bathtub right by the windows.

Stayed at this property?
Springwater, New York, United States
37 reviews   Superhost Wifi Available
ENTIRE HOME 9 Beds 16 Guests 5 Bedrooms 4 Bathrooms

Accommodates: 16

Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
the kitchen had all the amenities to make delicious meals for the family
Cleanliness:
the place was beautiful and clean
this is a beautiful and clean and unique place
the place was super clean
beautiful clean space with everything you could need inside the house
beautiful home super clean we had a lovely fall weekend
Host:
staff was responsive
Location:
great place and extraordinary location
the location is absolutely beautiful and we were able to take an amazing walk around the lake
great place to relax will return in the future
Read more reviews

9. Opulent Victorian-era farmhouse with seven bedrooms (from USD 520)

This grand Victorian home was built in the 1870s and has been meticulously maintained so that you feel like royalty during your stay here. The historic property has 7 bedrooms and can accommodate 10 guests. The home is surrounded by beautiful mowed lawns, and the privacy makes it ideal for parties and special events. The property also has a cosy backyard garden that leads to a private pool.

Stayed at this property?
Ithaca, New York, United States
35 reviews   Superhost Wifi Available
ENTIRE HOME 11 Beds 10 Guests 7 Bedrooms 3 Bathrooms

Accommodates: 10

Top guest reviews
Cleanliness:
pool and hot tub were clean as well as the rest of the property
Host:
ron is a super pleasant host
i had my bachelorette party here and it was great ron was a wonderful host
ron was very accommodating and made sure we were having fun and had everything we needed
ron is a fantastic host and his property is a perfect place to enjoy a weekend away
Location:
the location is very convenient and ron was great communication was very easy and always got prompt response
absolutely stunning my family and friends visited ron's place and loved it so much
Read more reviews

10. Modern guest house with one bedroom and a private pool (from USD 158)

Complete with amazing amenities such as a large deck, a cosy hot tub and a private pool, this lovely one-bedroom accommodation is perfect for couples. Various comfortable outdoor seating options make it a haven for people who enjoy sunbathing.

The home also features a fully equipped kitchen, fast Wi-Fi for remote workers and free on-site garage parking.

Stayed at this property?
Fayetteville, New York, United States
316 reviews   Superhost Wifi Available
Entire guesthouse 1 Bed 2 Guests 1 Bedroom 1 Bathroom

Accommodates: 2

Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
the kitchen was equipped with all the necessary items you need to make your stay perfect
the hot tub and pool are such a treat to dip in and then lounge around the water
adorable cozy getaway great location great amenities donna’s place truly felt like home
my wife and i greatly enjoyed our stay in donna’s apartment
the place was extremely tidy well maintained and cozy
Cleanliness:
very clean and homey
great clean little place for 2
clean organized and cozy
the pool is clean and well kept
house was exactly as described was beautifully decorated and clean
Host:
the hosts were unbelievably kind providing amazing breakfasts
donna is a fantastic host
they were very responsive to our needs and answered any questions immediately
very welcoming and friendly people
the hosts were very kind and helpful about places to visit
Location:
great place and great location
the location is great convenient to shopping and great restaurants
great location and good collection of brochures on nearby places to visit
stayed here for a weekend trip a cute and cozy place for two people
it was pretty restrictive of what we could do “after hours ” but other wise nice place
Read more reviews

Enjoy a relaxing and luxurious stay in Finger Lakes

The Finger Lakes region promises a plethora of fun attractions and activities for you to enjoy no matter how much time you are here for. From unique wineries to scenic natural landscapes, we are sure that you will find yourself with an overflowing itinerary before you know it. So treat yourself to a luxurious vacation rental with a relaxing pool so that you can unwind at the end of an exhausting day of sightseeing.

Stayed at this property?
Any must-sees we missed? Tell us about them in the comments section or write a post here to help out fellow travelers!
Disclosure: Trip101 selects the listings in our articles independently. Some of the listings in this article contain affiliate links.

History


Get Trip101 in your inbox

Unsubscribe in one click. See our Privacy Policy for more information on how we use your data

Being a military kid, Shamika has lived and travelled all over India, and her nomadic childhood has fueled an immense hunger and fascination for new cultures and languages (she's a polyglot!)...Read more

 Want to contribute as a Local Expert?
Explore New York
x
Good things are meant to be shared!
Back to top
Visited any of these places? Click this button to activate our "Add a Tip" feature to share your experience.