Anglers are drawn to the remarkable waterways of New York State, the habitat of 165 warm and cold-water fish species. Its vast coastline and 70,000 miles (112,654 kilometers) of streams and rivers provide endless fishing opportunities for anglers of all skill levels. 4 of the 50 best Bassmaster’s bass lakes are in the 7,500 ponds and lakes of the state. All tributaries connecting to the Lake Ontario and Salmon River are ideal for world-class sport fishing. The Catskill and Adirondack parks provide clear water streams and lakes for fly fishing. Head over to Long Island for saltwater fishing and catch fluke, bluefish, and bass. The small ponds of the Great Lakes are ideal for ice and deep-sea fishing. To make the most of your trip, book one of these top fishing lodges in New York State.
We handpicked these listings carefully, considering (wherever possible) host status, recent guest reviews, accommodation type, prices, availability of dates, decor, and a location with easy access to fishing spots. The image galleries get refreshed with the latest updates regularly. They were last updated on April 12, 2024.
1. Gorgeous lake house, Swan Lake (from USD 175)
Have a fun time at this lake house in stunning Swan Lake. Its two comfortable bedrooms guarantee guests a serene and restful sleep. You can enjoy a scrumptious breakfast which is part of their package. Submerge yourselves in the tranquil environment and be enchanted by the beauty of Swan Lake. Fishing will be most fun here because the lake is replete with largemouth bass, bluegill, pumpkinseed, and yellow perch.
Your fur baby is welcome too as the rental has a pet-friendly policy in place.
2. Lakefront vacation home, Wynantskill (from USD 175)
Flee to an oasis of lakeside serenity at this magical rental nestled among the picturesque rolling hills of Wynantskill. Situated by Snyder’s Lake, which is home to numerous types of fish such as largemouth bass, smallmouth bass, bluegill, and yellow perch, the property ensures a fun fishing retreat. Your adventures on the water continue as kayaks are available on the property. Guests can indulge in activities such as swimming and boating in the lake as well.
Take a load off and unwind afterward in the outdoor hot tub. The patio boasts gorgeous lake views while the balcony offers an elevated view of the surrounding area.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
everyone loved to views of the lake and the kids loved the bunk bedsthe beds were comfortable (always something we look for in a rental)Cleanliness:
the inside was very clean everything you could ever need was availableHost:
chris was a wonderful hostchris was a great hostother than that the owner is good about respondingchris is such a great host and we love nana's place on the waterhost is easy to work with and makes everything a breezeRead more reviewsLocation:
this is such a cute placethis was a cute welcoming property in a beautiful location and chris was great to work withit's closeness to albany and our family in averill park made it an ideal home away from homecan definitely see why this place would be great in the spring and summer as well
3. Tug Hill Cabin, Redfield (from USD 213)
This wooden fishing cabin in New York State is on Fox Road or Snowmobile Trail C-4, the main access to the Osceola and Oswego County ATV trails. During winter, guests can indulge in ATVing, skiing, and other outdoor activities. Salmon River Reservoir is just 2 miles (3.2 kilometers) away, where you can go fishing, boating, and swimming. Pubs and restaurants are within 10 miles (16 kilometers).
This cabin is fully equipped to house up to nine guests. The main floor features a snug living room and enough seats for eight people in the dining and kitchen area. Linens are provided for in the four bedrooms split into two floors. Firewood is provided for the fire pit on the well-manicured lawn. Fire up the propane grill on the porch to enjoy a barbecue dinner.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
the cabin had all of the amenities needed for a comfortable staythe beds where super comfythe beds were really comfortable and perfect for a good nights sleepCleanliness:
the cabin is clean and cozyit was very clean upon arrivalthe cabin was clean and well stockedclean private and relaxing getawayvery good and clean cabin in a quiet areaHost:
the owner was very responsive to answer any questionsowners were very communicative and made the process super easyowners were great to deal with very quick to respond to any questionsowners were very responsive and was quick to help when we needed the parking area plowed outRead more reviewsLocation:
great location to the trailsbeautiful cabin - nice private locationvery nice and good locationalways a good time here and great locationgreat experience here tucked away in a beautiful place
4. Riverside house with a dock, Hastings (from USD 521)
The house is one of two riverside homes sharing a dock and private driveway on the shores of the Oneida River. It can sleep 12 guests comfortably in its 5 bedrooms spread over 2 floors. The main floor has an open concept that allows guests to dine, cook, and lounge with panoramic river views from its floor-to-ceiling windows.
Enjoy playing various outdoor games such as volleyball and horseshoe in the grassy yard. Cross the yard to reach the water’s edge for bass fishing, boating, and swimming or simply relax on loungers and soak up the natural beauty around.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
very good tv and wifi receptionthey also loved swimming canoes and feeding the chickens and rabbits that wonder around on the propertysince it was a hot humid time we were very appreciative of the air conditioningthe five bedrooms and two full baths were terrific because there were three king beds among themHost:
owner was flexible with times and very helpfulit was the best place to start our new year and the owner is very generous and friendlyRead more reviewsLocation:
lots of room for everyone great fishing off the dock and close to shopping and restaurants
5. Weeping Willow, Fleischmanns (from USD 550)
Want to go fly fishing in your lodge in New York? Choose this fully restored and upgraded 19th-century Queen Anne mansion is 2 miles (3.2 kilometers) from Belleayre Mountain in Fleischmanns. The nearby Esopus Creek is stocked with wild brown and rainbow trout. There are also several hiking and biking trails nearby.
After an active day out, you can relax on the wraparound porch and enjoy mountain views or on the huge deck where you can also fire up the grill to cook your catch of the day. The mansion has 6 bedrooms and 15 beds and can sleep up to 22 guests. A heating system warms the main floor, while guests are watching their favorite shows on the 32-inch HDTV in the classic parlor. The elegant dining room featuring a wine cooler, wet bar, and a butler pantry is adjacent to the modern Viking kitchen.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
good common spaces for large families and a large functional kitchen with excellent waresit has plenty of room and beds to fit a large informal group of friendsliving room area has entertainment system are nicely set upall linen was fresh and the beds were extra softthe family room has a ton of board games for kids to playCleanliness:
the house smelled fresh and really cleanthe bedding linens and towels are cleanour room was super clean however one family said their bed sheet was stained and dirtythe house was clean with lots of room to spread outattic and basement bathrooms were clean the common bathroom needs updateHost:
owners easy to communicate withRead more reviewsLocation:
central located in fleischmann's with a nice park right across the streetthe location is also great because it's so close to belleayre ski center and other area attractions
6. Lakefront cabin with a screened porch, Altmar (from USD 375)
Planning a fishing trip with family and friends? Then, book this lakefront fishing cabin in New York State that’s an absolute joy for the outdoorsy. Here, you can go fishing off the private dock and boating and kayaking in the nearby Fawn Lake by Salmon River during summer. Plus, you have access to snowmobile trails and an ATV system during winter. The cabin requires at least a seven-night stay during the summer months and a minimum of three nights during the fall season.
It also offers four spacious bedrooms and two full bathrooms spread across two floors. The main floor features a modern open kitchen, a dining set for six, and a cozy lounge with a satellite TV. The screened porch and a back patio offer refreshing lake views while dining alfresco.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
plenty of beds and amenities with large family room for relaxation by the fireplaceit is beautifully decorated with comfy furniture and beds and has everything you could possibly needwe wanted a rental that would have as many amenities on-site as possible: swimming boating fishing and relaxingCleanliness:
the house was clean and very accommodatingthe house was clean and spaciousclean plenty of room perfectly maintained and there's never a problemthe house itself was very clean and spacious with plenty of room for the 6 of usthe house is well kept very clean and in a great locationHost:
really appreciate the great ownersthe owners were very responsive to any issue we hadhoward was responsive to any questions or concerns that we hadhost’s are excellent would definitely stay againthe owners were incredibly responsive during the stay addressing issues quickly efficiently and wellRead more reviewsLocation:
great location close to the salmon riverlocation was perfect for snowmobilinghouse is just perfectly sized and location is greatwas close to river and easy access to findgreat location close to fishing and very roomy
7. Spacious cabin near Lake Chautauqua, Jamestown (from USD 250)
This rustic cabin is the perfect home base for anglers. It is five minutes away from Lake Chautauqua, which is a great place for sport fishing. The lake is brimming with large and smallmouth bass, panfish, and muskellunge. This private 30-acre (12.14-hectare) woodland property is also a 5-minute drive away from Bemus Point Village.
It also has three spacious bedrooms and a two-tier deck overlooking the private spring-fed lake surrounded by lush foliage. Enjoy the outdoors by having barbecues on the back patio, warming up around the fire pit, and relaxing in the private pergola by the lake.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
the two bedrooms were comfortable and the large loft was perfect for teensCleanliness:
the cabin was very nice and clean and the accommodations were very comfortableHost:
working with the owner was awesomedefinitely used bottled water as host suggestedthe owners couldn’t have been more helpful throughout the whole processbeautiful property beware of ownerwhat we liked best was the seclusion owners are very cooperative and handled all issues encounteredRead more reviewsLocation:
very remote but also comforting quiet and peace-fullperfect place to relax and get away for some r&rquiet and dark at night very relaxing
8. Lovely house with a furnished deck, Cooperstown (from USD 390)
This house is on vast farmland on Highway 28 in the Cooperstown area near Dreams Park. The property is surrounded by mountains, wildlife, wineries, and breweries. Active guests can indulge in paddle boating at the nearby Ostego Lake or go fishing in the well-stocked pond.
There’s a fire pit for nighttime s'mores or fire up the grill on the deck to enjoy a barbecue dinner. The house also comes with three bedrooms and can sleep up to six people comfortably. A minimum of three-night stay is required during off seasons and on regular seasons, six nights.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
very well stocked home with lots of space in the living room dining room and kitchenroom and a terrific kitchen - roomy including any and all appliances/utensils/cookware that you could possibly needonly improvement i could see would be some more comfortable bedscomfortable beds relaxing family/tCleanliness:
the house was very clean and the property is beautifulcomfortable clean perfect setting beautiful scenerysuper clean and fully stocked with everything you needHost:
the owner was kind communicative and responsiveboth the house and the owner were wonderfulowner was super accessible and great to work withRead more reviewsLocation:
amazing place close to the ballparkgreat location to cooperstown dreams parklocation was perfect for everything in the cooperstown areagreat property that is literally a 1 minute drive to dreams parkwe had a lovely time at the house enviably close to the dreams park
9. Cozy cottage near Salmon River, Pulaski (from USD 204)
Are you planning to go fly fishing in Salmon River? Then, this lovely lakefront cottage is just for you! It’s near the river positioned over a high break wall on Ramona Beach, offering panoramic views of Lake Ontario. It’s a short distance to boat launches.
This four-bedroom cottage provides cozy shelter for six guests, including kids. It has a modern kitchen, a dining area, and front and back patios for outdoor lounging. The well-manicured yard features a sandbox for kids and parking for trailers, boats, and RVs.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
we had everything we needed and the fireplace kept it perfectly cozy at nightthe description is accurate and the house has a rustic comfortable charmCleanliness:
cottage was clean and well kepthouse was very clean and it had everything you need (ie: towels beach towels kitchen utensils dishes etcbedrooms are very small but adequate and cleaneverything was in super nice clean condition we will definitely come back againlovely hearing the waves clean and cozy thank youHost:
the owner was great too he responded quickly to a text i sent him and was very accommodatingowner was very easy to deal with and get in touch withit is cozy friendly and homelyit was nice to see old pictures of the owners family on the wallsthe owners were very nice and i think it would be great for people without asthma/dust allergiesRead more reviewsLocation:
positives: location location location house was large and cleangreat yard for kids and pets selkirk shores park is 1always a great place to stay
10. Country-style cabin with fantastic mountain views, Andes (from USD 217)
This country-style cabin is within walking distance of a lake and pond surrounded by lush greenery. There are also several hiking trails nearby. You can hike down ShaverdownTrail to a pond overlooking a reservoir and further down to a rock ledge. Boating, kayaking, canoeing, sailing, and fishing is allowed in the adjoining streams and reservoir.
From the living room’s couch and front deck, you can enjoy unobstructed views of the surrounding natural beauty. This cabin also features high cathedral ceilings, rustic wooden interiors, a wide balcony, and entertainment facilities such as flat-screen TVs, DVD players, high-speed DSL, and Wi-Fi. Six people can sleep across its three bedrooms. A minimum stay of two nights is required here.
11. Fully furnished lodge for large groups, Stony Creek (from USD 2464)
This 12-bedroom lodge in Stony Creek is perfect for family getaways and friends reunions. It is nestled at the foothills of the Adirondack Mountains. The Harrisburg Lake is steps away from the property, where you can indulge in fishing, kayaking, swimming, and canoeing. SUPs, kayaks and canoes are available for guests’ use.
The on-site Hitching Post Tavern provides family-friendly entertainment with music and dancing. Guests can opt to partake in the chef-prepared meals or cook their own food in the fully equipped kitchen. Kids will enjoy the nightly bonfire with free s'mores.
12. Family-friendly waterfront cottage for eight, Hastings (from USD 252)
This family-friendly cottage on the shores of Oneida Lake can fit up to eight guests in its two spacious bedrooms. It also features a screened porch, a sprawling yard for parking your boat or car, and two private boat docks.
The property is steps away from the lake waters, so guests can go ice fishing anytime. Though Oneida Lake is popular for bass fishing, yellow perch and walleye fish are bountiful at this location. It’s best to fish from the shore during summer nights using stick baits and blade baits.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
relaxing good water location modern bathroom air conditioning screen room docks for fishingthe cottage was everything we hoped it would be: quiet comfortable and right on the lakelarge yard space means it was easy to have a few relatives over for swims/socially distanced visitsCleanliness:
good clean sheets and towels good tv & internet was greatRead more reviewsHost:
overall great place great hosti don't think i have ever had a nicer host in all of my experiencesit was a really lovely stay and i would absolutely rent from this host again
The Empire State is an angler's paradise
New York State is best appreciated when you explore its unique natural terrain, including its fishing grounds. The rentals listed above offer the coziest shelters with modern comforts and locations convenient for sport fishing. When planning your next fishing expedition, make sure to include these top fishing lodges in New York State in your travel plans.
Sensing a change in opinion? Maybe you want to stay close to the beach or indulge in a peculiar mix of serenity and luxury. Well, there’s no need to fret! Your urge to stay near the beach can easily be satisfied at the lovely beach houses in New York State. And for those who want to spoil themselves with beauty, there are some gorgeous lakefront hotels in New York State that will do the trick.
Frequently asked questions about fishing lodges in New York State
History
Get Trip101 in your inbox
Unsubscribe in one click. See our Privacy Policy for more information on how we use your data
Create an account to