8 Best Italian Restaurants In Madison, New Jersey

italian restaurants in madison nj
| 4 min read

The Morris County borough of Madison, New Jersey, is a quaint city known for its history, culture, and many lakes and parks. When you visit Madison, you will be surprised by the number of things the city offers. Be it the Museum of Early Trades & Crafts, the Frelinghuysen Arboretum, Watchung Reservation, Loantaka Brook, or the Great Swamp. There is enough to keep one entertained and busy during their vacation here. The vibrant city life of Madison and the diverse food scene allows locals and visitors to enjoy a range of global cuisine from around the world. And one such cuisine that has taken the area by storm is Italian. Check out this guide for the best Italian restaurants in Madison, New Jersey.

1. Osteria Trevi

Editor's Note: Photo taken from the establishment's official social account

Happy flags week! From Osteria Trevi.

Posted by Osteria TREVI on Tuesday, June 16, 2015

Nestled in a lovely neighborhood, Osteria Trevi is a casual Italian restaurant serving scrumptious food that is loved by the locals of Madison. The exposed walls of the building give a rustic look to the restaurant and the cozy space within the walls sets a nice mood for dining. The cordial and quick service is just the cherry on top.

You can find an array of items to choose from here. Some of them include eggplant parmigiana, gluten-free homemade meatballs, penne with Bolognese meat sauce and mascarpone cheese, and pan-roasted chicken, among others.

Osteria Trevi

Address: 4 Park Ave, Madison, NJ 07940, United States

Website: Osteria Trevi

Opening hours: Mon - Thu: 12pm - 2:30pm & 5pm - 9pm; Fri: 12pm - 2:30pm & 5pm - 10pm; Sat: 5pm - 10pm (closed on Sun)

Visited this place?

2. Il Mondo Vecchio

An exclusive BYOB restaurant in Madison, New Jersey, II Mondo Vecchio is a traditional Italian restaurant, serving all-time Italian classics. Decorated as an antique parlor, the restaurant feels intimate and casual and a great spot to have a fantastic dining experience. Since this is a BYOB restaurant, you won’t burn a hole in your pocket when it comes to enjoying some wine with your meal.

Most people come here to celebrate a special occasion or milestone and it’s not the kind of place that you would come to regularly to dine at on a daily or weekly basis. The quaint restaurant exudes a high-end feeling that can’t be ignored the moment you step into the restaurant.

Il Mondo Vecchio

Address: 72 Main St #1, Madison, NJ 07940, United States

Website: Il Mondo Vecchio

Opening hours: Mon - Thu: 11:45am - 2:45pm & 5pm - 9:30pm; Fri: 11:45am - 2:45pm & 5pm - 10:30pm; Sat: 4:30pm - 10:30pm (closed on Sun)

Visited this place?

3. Il Goccino Ristorante

Editor's Note: Photo taken from the establishment's official social account

Although Italian restaurants are found aplenty in Madison, New Jersey, only a few stand out. One of these spots is II Goccino Ristorante. The cozy ambiance and contemporary decor make it a surreal spot to enjoy dining, either with your family or friends. All the dishes on the menu are prepared carefully and from scratch using locally sourced ingredients.

Some of the noteworthy dishes you must try on your visit here are their gamberi di cocktail – a shrimp cocktail served with homemade spicy sauce, pasta e Fagioli, grilled chicken, and linguine all’ vongole – a linguini pasta mixed with baby clams, garlic, and olive oil, in a white or red sauce.

Il Goccino Ristorante

Address: 33 Main St, Madison, NJ 07940, United States

Website: Il Goccino Ristorante

Opening hours: Mon - Fri: 11:30am - 3pm & 4pm - 10pm; Sat: 4pm - 11pm; Sun: 1pm - 9pm

Visited this place?

4. L'Allegria

Have a beautiful culinary journey when you visit L'allegria in Madison, New Jersey. A high-end and trendy restaurant, L'Allegria is popular among its patrons for serving top Italian food since its opening. This alfresco dining spot boasts a Mediterranean courtyard with a casual atmosphere and an intimate setting that is perfect for a dinner date, lunch meeting, or a get-together.

Some of the best items on their menu are their zuppa di vongole o zozze (farm-raised mussels or tiny neck clams dipped in red or white sauce), antipasto della casa (a bowl full of marinated and grilled vegetables), and fusilli napoletani (handmade pasta with buffalo ricotta and Sunday ragu), among others.


Address: 11 Prospect St, Madison, NJ 07940, United States

Website: L'Allegria

Opening hours: 12pm - 10pm (daily)

Visited this place?

5. Romanelli's Pizza & Italian Eatery

A cafeteria cum pizza joint in Madison, New Jersey, Romanelli’s Pizza & Italian Eatery was established in 1970. Famed for serving Italian mains, sandwiches, and more, the eatery is also known for organizing weekly kids’ night. This family-friendly restaurant is open every day, so you’ll get to taste its Italian magic whenever your heart, taste buds, and bellies crave it.

The decor is modern and the vibe is casual and chill. It serves an array of dishes, like cheese pizza, old-fashioned bruschetta pie, meat lovers pizza, stuffed shells, vegetable lasagna, and so much more.

Romanelli's Pizza & Italian Eatery

Address: 42 Lincoln Pl, Madison, NJ 07940, United States

Website: Romanelli’s Pizza & Italian Eatery

Opening hours: Mon - Thu: 11am - 10pm; Fri - Sat: 11am - 10pm; Sun: 12pm - 10pm

Visited this place?

6. Rocco's Tuscany Bar and Grill

Craving Italian food? Need a place to go, but can’t really think of anywhere? How about checking out Rocco’s Tuscany Bar and Grill? This eatery is known for serving an array of lunch and dinner items to its patrons. Some of the appetizers worth trying here are their crab cakes, calamari, and more. You can also opt for a fresh salad if that’s your thing. The salads are prepared using fresh vegetables and ingredients, which makes them some of the more popular dishes on the menu.

There’s also homemade paninis, ciabatta rolls, black Angus beef, penne arrabbiata, and lasagna, among other dishes for you to try.

Rocco's Tuscany Bar and Grill

Address: 30 Cook Ave, Madison, NJ 07940, United States

Website: Rocco’s Tuscany Bar and Grill

Opening hours: Mon - Fri: 11am - 2pm & 4pm - 10pm; Sat: 3pm - 10pm; Sun: 4pm - 11pm

Visited this place?

7. Italian Village Pizza

Established in 1981, Italian Village Pizza is located in a strip mall, the perfect spot for shoppers to visit and gobble up some of the tasty items from the menu. Italian Village Pizza is affordable, but that doesn’t mean the pizzeria skimps on authenticity. To give a glimpse of their varied menu, some of the food items on offer include their mozzarella sticks, chicken parmigiana dinner, fried shrimp platter, buffalo wings, stuffed pizza, Hawaiian pizza, and more.

If you can’t come in and dine here, you should know that the establishment also delivers your favorite items to your doorstep.

Italian Village Pizza

Address: 300 Main St, Madison, NJ 07940, United States

Website: Italian Village Pizza

Opening hours: Mon - Sat: 10am - 10pm; Sun: 11am - 10pm

Visited this place?

8. Nicky’s Firehouse Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria

A firehouse-themed American BYOB restaurant, Nicky’s Firehouse Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria opened its doors to the public nearly 30 years ago. Sitting in downtown Madison, NJ, this cozy eatery serves a range of mouthwatering pizzas, seafood, veal, paninis, pasta, and so much more.

This family-friendly restaurant offers an experience unlike any other and it will make you feel like you are dining at home. The only difference is that here is you will get dishes prepared by experienced chefs and pleasant service. Try their fried calamari, Firehouse Wings, artichokes Milanese, pasta Fagioli, grandma’s pizza, and more.

Nicky’s Firehouse Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria

Address: 15 Central Ave, Madison, NJ 07940, United States

Website: Nicky’s Firehouse Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria

Opening hours: Mon - Sat: 11am - 10pm; Sun: 3pm - 9pm

Visited this place?

Enjoy the Italian cuisine in Madison

Pasta dish
Source: Pixabay

The Italian food scene in Madison is worth a try, as it provides an array of rich flavors that one must not miss. Enjoy the unique taste of Italy in every dish at these Italian eateries in Madison, New Jersey.

Visited this place?
Any must-sees we missed? Tell us about them in the comments section or write a post here to help out fellow travelers!
Disclosure: Trip101 selects the listings in our articles independently. Some of the listings in this article contain affiliate links.


Get Trip101 in your inbox

Unsubscribe in one click. See our Privacy Policy for more information on how we use your data

Born in Mumbai and brought up in Bangalore, India, Aarti is a full-time freelance writer by profession. She is a lover of everything the ‘blue dot’ offers—world cultures, off-the-beaten tracks,...Read more

 Want to contribute as a Local Expert?
Explore Madison
Looking for accommodation?
Good things are meant to be shared!
Back to top
Visited any of these places? Click this button to activate our "Add a Tip" feature to share your experience.