10 Best Airbnb Vacation Rentals In Sylvan Beach, New York

Melanie
Contributing Writer
Updated
| 5 min read

Located along the shores of Oneida Lake, Sylvan Beach offers plenty of fun and entertainment for visitors and locals alike. Swimming is one of the most popular activities here, as is fishing for walleye and bass. Boating, beach volleyball, sailing, and kayaking are among the other things you can experience here. The highlight of the trip, here, however, is a visit to Sylvan Beach Amusement Park, a vintage amusement park that offers a combination of fun rides, arcade games, and access to the beach. There are plenty of family-friendly activities that await you in this area, so be sure to book one of the best Airbnb vacation rentals in Sylvan Beach, New York, and give yourself plenty of time to explore and have fun.

We handpicked these listings carefully, considering (wherever possible) Superhost status, recent guest reviews, location, accommodation type, prices, availability of dates, decor, and amenities. The image galleries get refreshed with the latest updates regularly. They were last updated on October 31, 2024.

Why Trust Trip101?

Over 50,000 articles reviewed and published by our experienced team

Over 50 years of combined experience researching, writing and reviewing travel articles

Over 40,000 hours spent on research and fact-checking from credible sources (last year’s data)

Optimizing content from data-driven insights collected directly from users on our platform

Focus on authentic and up-to-date information by collaborating with local guides, global travelers and other industry experts

Long-standing partnerships with credible brands like Airbnb, Booking.com, Agoda, Expedia, GetYourGuide, Viator, RVShare and more

Full disclosure on any partnerships or sponsored content

Trip101’s team of writers, editors, and content managers oversees the publication of all travel content, including destination guides, accommodation recommendations, and travel tips. They have extensive experience in the travel industry and no content, written or visual, gets published without a review. Many of our team’s work has also been featured in Travel+Leisure, National Today, The Indian Express, The Telegraph (India), Robb Report, The Adventure Handbook, Tripoto, Korea Tourism Organization, and Korean Ministry of Culture, Sports and Tourism. Some of them are also members of professional organizations like the Society of American Travel Writers and the International Travel Writers and Photographers Alliance.

Each member of the team follows Trip101's methodology and strict editorial guidelines to ensure accuracy, authenticity, and relevance.

1. Luxury villa steps away from the beach (from USD 124)

This beautiful villa is as practical as it is stylish, with its vaulted ceilings and granite counters. The rental is fully furnished for a comfortable stay and includes a well-equipped kitchen equipped with stainless steel appliances that make cooking a breeze. Some books, toys, and board games are provided for family-friendly fun. This property is just a few steps away from the water, where you can enjoy outdoor entertainment. The property is also within walking distance of shops and restaurants.

The property has outdoor seating so you can relax and enjoy the views.

Stayed at this property?
Sylvan Beach, New York, United States

15.45 km (9.6 mi) from Turning Stone Resort Casino
123 reviews   Superhost Wifi Available
ENTIRE CONDO 2 Beds 5 Guests 2 Bedrooms 2 Bathrooms

Accommodates: 5

Top guest reviews
Host:
the owner was very responsive to our minor issue
carl was very responsive to all questions check in was easy and slyvan beach is really cute
brand new beautiful accommodations and a host that inquires how you are doing
luxury family friendly very well equipped very attentive host prime location by the water the list goes on
carl was very responsive and very accommodating to any requests
Location:
perfect location for a trip to sylvan beach
everything about this villa was perfectly suited for us close to the beach quiet modern and spacious
we had a fantastic visit - great layout and convenient location
beautiful upscale condo within walking distance of the lake and adorable town
thanks again for this amazing place to stay will be back again next year
Cleanliness:
very clean and organized house
very clean and fully equipped
it was extremely clean and expertly decorated
spacious clean well equipped
it was clean and well supplied with kitchen items bedding and towels
Amenities & Room:
the beds were so comfortable
comfortable and quiet as well
Read more reviews

2. The Lilly Pad (from USD 79)

This holiday home is centrally located, putting you not only within walking distance of the beach but also some of the top restaurants and attractions in the area. If you prefer to cook your own food, don’t worry, because this rental has a well-equipped kitchen you can use to whip up your favorite dishes. Alternatively, you can use the grill if you want to have a cookout, which you can enjoy in the outdoor dining area.

This rental welcomes pets, which makes this a great option if you can’t bear to leave Fido behind.

Stayed at this property?
Blossvale, New York, United States

14.87 km (9.3 mi) from Turning Stone Resort Casino
68 reviews   Superhost Wifi Available
Entire guest suite 2 Beds 4 Guests 1 Bedroom 1 Bathroom

Accommodates: 4

Top guest reviews
Host:
great place great host who was very accommodating
the house we nice and the host always responded when we had questions
troy was very responsive on any needs
the owners clearly puts a lot of work and thought into maintaining the property
Location:
great location and everything is walking distance
lovely place in a great location
great location within walking distance to plenty of food and stuff to do
the lilly pad was the perfect place for our girls trip
the place is great and good location
Cleanliness:
a very clean and convenient stay
very clean and well thought out
the place was clean and perfect for us
clean efficient and lots of communication make this a great find in this area
troy’s place was clean and well equipped
Amenities & Room:
very short walk to the beach great wifi and great water pressure
the bed was incredibly comfortable
Read more reviews

3. AJ's Beach House (from USD 99)

This beautifully decorated and well-equipped rental is a great accommodation option regardless of whether you’re visiting for work or for leisure. There’s a dedicated workspace and Wi-Fi that you can use if you need to do something work-related. Meanwhile, a Smart TV, some books, and reading materials are provided for your entertainment.

The beach is just minutes away from the property. Several beach bars and the casino are also accessible on foot if you want to check out the local nightlife. Restaurants are close by as well.

Stayed at this property?
Sylvan Beach, New York, United States

14.91 km (9.3 mi) from Turning Stone Resort Casino
142 reviews   Wifi Available
ENTIRE HOME 3 Beds 6 Guests 3 Bedrooms 1 Bathroom

Accommodates: 6

Top guest reviews
Host:
the home is very family friendly i would definitely being my family here for another stay
aj was a great host and excellent communication
there was lots to do and aj the host was very helpful with anything we needed
aj is very responsive and touches base to make sure all is well
he was also flexible with check-in and check-out times which was extremely helpful
Location:
great location and comfortable home
super cute place near the beach and restaurants
location is great for fishing and beach access
the house was as expected and the location was great
great location and great space would definitely visit again
Cleanliness:
beautiful place clean and convenient
impeccably clean and decoration is done so well
super comfy beds and very clean
great place really clean and nicely decorated
the house was very clean and well decorated
Amenities & Room:
spacious and comfortable with lots of amenities
plenty of blankets & pillows to get comfortable
lovely place comfortable beds great air conditioning and aj's clear and timely directions made it easy to check in
the beds were very comfortable
this beautiful little cozy cottage was perfect for our annual best friends get away
Read more reviews

4. Cute and cozy cottage (from USD 165)

This cozy cottage has everything that you may need for a fun and relaxing stay. A kitchen, a grill, and laundry facilities are among the practical amenities that you can find here. A fire pit is available if you want to sit around a bonfire. The bedrooms are equipped with room-darkening shades to help you get a good night’s rest.

The beach is just two blocks away from the property. Also close by are some restaurants, shops, and bars. Additionally, you can try your luck at the local casino.

Stayed at this property?
Sylvan Beach, New York, United States

14.82 km (9.3 mi) from Turning Stone Resort Casino
118 reviews   Superhost Wifi Available
Entire cottage 2 Beds 4 Guests 2 Bedrooms 1 Bathroom

Accommodates: 4

Top guest reviews
Host:
hosts were super responsive
the hosts were great
excellent hosts and a great cottage to enjoy with friends
Location:
cute cottage with a great location
super cute cottage in great location
cute place very close to town and the lake
great little place close to all the fun
it was great close to the beach all the items we needed for our stay
Cleanliness:
everything smelled nice and clean upon arrival
clean and exactly what is described
it was immaculately clean and tastefully decorated
great location very clean brandon was great with communication
very cute quaint cottage very clean & super close to everything excellent communication recommend booking with brandon and cassidy
Amenities & Room:
best of all the beds were comfy and the ac's were much needed escape from the hot weekend
the air conditioners in each room were a lifesaver plenty of towels pillows and blankets
comfortable beds super clean ice cold air conditioning
such a comfortable and relaxing place to stay
Read more reviews

New York Tour Guide

Annie Leguennec

Annie Leguennec

My name is Annie. I am a local Tour guide based in Philadelphia enjoying fully what the city has to offer with its deep history, street arts, murals, architecture, traditional food, black history, Farmer Markets, green space, a melting pot of neighborhoods and its great locals. I am looking for to welcome you and show you this incredible city where you will gain a better understanding of the ci... Read more

Tours by Annie

5. Beach house with kayak and paddle boat rentals (from USD 270)

The hosts of this beach house provide beach essentials such as chairs, floats, an umbrella, and a pop-up tent to amp up your holiday. What’s more? They also rent out kayaks and paddle boats. Prefer to do your exploring on land? Two bikes are provided for guests as well.

The rental itself is well-furnished and family-friendly. A crib, a high chair, and children’s dinnerware are provided so you don’t have to bring your own. Baby-safe gates and outlet covers may also be installed for the protection of your little one.

Stayed at this property?
Sylvan Beach, New York, United States

15.17 km (9.5 mi) from Turning Stone Resort Casino
40 reviews   Superhost Wifi Available
ENTIRE HOME 6 Beds 8 Guests 3 Bedrooms 2 Bathrooms

Accommodates: 8

Top guest reviews
Host:
edie and dan were great hosts
edie and dan were great hosts and answered any questions promptly
lovely home and edie and daniel were so flexible and communicative
really friendly and made us feel at home
hosts were amazing just like the house
Location:
great location just steps from the beach
the house was nice and close to everything
house is in a great location at sylvan beach
the perfect spot for beach fun and close to everything
a great location right in the hidden gem of sylvan beach
Cleanliness:
clean comfortable and spacious
the house is clean and spacious
very comfortable convenient and clean house
the nearby verona beach state park was excellent - safe and clean playgrounds sprinklers and food
i would highly recommend this property if you want a clean restful and fun experience
Amenities & Room:
great stay there were 7 of us and plenty of room for everyone
Read more reviews

6. Lemon Drop Cottage (from USD 200)

Lemon Drop Cottage is all about providing a fun experience for guests. Not only are beach supplies such as kayaks, floats, and toys provided by the host, but the property also has a game room if you want to have fun indoors.

Pets will also have fun on the property thanks to the fenced-in backyard. Humans will also love this area because it is equipped with outdoor dining furniture, a grill, and a fire pit. An outdoor shower is available so you can rinse off after swimming at the lake.

Stayed at this property?
Sylvan Beach, New York, United States

15.28 km (9.5 mi) from Turning Stone Resort Casino
74 reviews   Superhost Wifi Available
ENTIRE HOME 5 Beds 8 Guests 3 Bedrooms 1 Bathroom

Accommodates: 8

Top guest reviews
Host:
ariel was a really great host we would surely come back again
she's very responsive and accommodating
it’s just so nice to stay somewhere where clearly the owner wants you to be absolutely looked after
seriously the cutest place ever as an airbnb host myself i took notes during our stay
Location:
perfect location as it was a quick walk to a nice private beach
good location stocked with everything you need
i wish i could give higher than 5 stars great location so much to do
nice home close to town
there was so much stuff for our kids to do and the location was perfect
Cleanliness:
nice and clean
the house is adorable and was so clean
super clean with lots of extras ariel thought of it all
Read more reviews

7. Spacious remodeled cottage (from USD 1141)

Consider this rental if you’re looking for a rental that can accommodate a large group. This newly remodeled cottage is a family-friendly option that comes with a crib, a changing table, and a high chair, which is great if you plan on bringing an infant with you on your trip.

The interiors and exteriors are both well-furnished. Inside, you can find amenities such as a kitchen and laundry facilities. Outside, you can find a patio, a grill, and a fire pit. There’s even a playground so kids can have fun.

Stayed at this property?
Sylvan Beach, New York, United States

15.13 km (9.5 mi) from Turning Stone Resort Casino
37 reviews   Wifi Available
ENTIRE HOME 10 Beds 10 Guests 3 Bedrooms 1 Bathroom

Accommodates: 10

Top guest reviews
Host:
ricky is a great host
rick was very accommodating and a great host
ricky was great- super responsive friendly and eager to help
ricky is a lovely host who truly cares about providing a great experience for his guests
rick is great and very attentive to his guests
Location:
location was also great quiet but still close to town
great house great location and outstanding hospitality looking forward to staying with you for the third time next summer
5 minute walk to the beach great playground out back nice fire pit spacious and clean
great place to stay
Cleanliness:
ricky consistently makes a great effort to make his homes clean and comfortable
Amenities & Room:
the bbq grill is awesome and the kitchen is roomy
Read more reviews

8. Luxurious boathouse near Main Street (from USD 350)

This designer boathouse comes with two private decks so you don’t have to worry about sharing the space with strangers as you watch the boats pass by. The lower deck comes with a barbecue you can use if you want to have a cookout. Also in the outdoor area is a fire pit that you are welcome to use if you want to sit around the fire as dusk falls.

The boathouse has a kitchen if you want to cook your own meals. Amenities for entertainment include a Smart TV, a sound system, and some board games. Main Street, the casino, and the beach are all easily accessible from the property.

Stayed at this property?
Sylvan Beach, New York, United States

14.49 km (9.1 mi) from Turning Stone Resort Casino
20 reviews   Wifi Available
Entire cottage 3 Beds 4 Guests 2 Bedrooms 1 Bathrooms

Accommodates: 4

Top guest reviews
Host:
the host made us feel at home and comfortable
Location:
great location for sylvan beach
place is very nice and right in the middle of town
wow this “boat house” was just what we needed for a quiet weekend away
Cleanliness:
extremely clean and well appointed
this place was amazing everything was very clean and new
very beautiful and clean
Read more reviews

9. Historical beach cottage (from USD 131)

This charming cottage is over 100 years old but has been updated with modern furnishings, including updated kitchen appliances and laundry facilities, for guests’ comfort. The rental also has a fenced backyard, where you can have a barbecue or sit around the fire pit.

Shops, restaurants, and the beach are accessible on foot from the property. Sylvan Beach Amusement Park is also just two blocks away from the rental. Guests can bring a dog that weighs up to 23 lbs (10.4 kgs), provided that they settle the corresponding pet fee.

Stayed at this property?
Sylvan Beach, New York, United States

14.64 km (9.1 mi) from Turning Stone Resort Casino
103 reviews   Superhost Wifi Available
Entire bungalow 5 Beds 6 Guests 2 Bedrooms 1 Bathroom

Accommodates: 6

Top guest reviews
Host:
the communication from hosts was fast and reliable much appreciated
great home to stay in and friendly town with a lot of things to see and do
Location:
great location can walk to everything
nice and walking distance from beach
the location is perfect
great location & had everything we needed
it is close to the beach ( lake) restaurants and a beautiful walking path to catch the sunset
Cleanliness:
the house was clean and very welcoming
the place was charming and sparkling clean
the house was cozy warm and clean
great communication clean pet friendly and close to the beach and downtown
this place was a great find accommodating and very clean
Amenities & Room:
the house is absolutely adorable cozy lake house vibes that would be perfect for all seasons
Read more reviews

10. The Cove House

This lake house has been recently renovated to make guests feel as comfortable as possible. The kitchen is furnished with the necessities so you can cook your favorite dishes. The second-floor balcony, meanwhile, has a grill that you can also use for food preparation. Towels and linens are provided so you don’t have to bring your own.

Parking for one vehicle is available right on the property. Check with your host if you want to bring your pets with you - up to two dogs are welcome here, subject to the host’s approval.

Stayed at this property?
Sylvan Beach , New York, United States

14.5 km (9.1 mi) from Turning Stone Resort Casino
25 reviews   Superhost Wifi Available
ENTIRE HOME 4 Beds 6 Guests 2 Bedrooms 2 Bathrooms

Accommodates: 6

Top guest reviews
Host:
chase is a great host—quick to communicate and welcomes questions
the hosts were extremely responsive prior to booking
the host were very responsive and within minutes
we enjoyed our stay and host is very communicative
the owners were very responsive and check in and out was easy and seamless
Location:
it was a great location and great stay
it’s in a great location to walk to restaurants and the lake
chase’s place is so nice the location is absolutely perfect
walking distance to lake and erie canal amusement park restaurants and ice cream
walking distance to restaurants gift shops and casino
Cleanliness:
place was very clean and spacious
the house was spotless the linens were crisp and clean
nice clean place in downtown sylvan beach
the house is very clean and open
place was very clean and the house was in a convenient place
Read more reviews

See the best of Sylvan Beach

New York may best be known for its skyscrapers, but it also features spots such as Sylvan Beach where you can surround yourself with nature. Choose from these options as your first step to enjoying a relaxing holiday by the lake.

Any must-sees we missed? Tell us about them in the comments section or write a post here to help out fellow travelers!
Disclosure: Trip101 selects the listings in our articles independently. Some of the listings in this article contain affiliate links.

History

Get Trip101 in your inbox

Unsubscribe in one click. See our Privacy Policy for more information on how we use your data

Melanie is a freelance travel writer. She considers freelancing for Trip 101 to be a combination of two of the things she loves: writing and traveling. She has gone sightseeing with family,...Read more

 Want to contribute as a Local Expert?
Register Here
0 Comments
Good things are meant to be shared!