Sodus Point is a hidden gem in Wayne County, Upstate New York. It’s a small village fronting Lake Ontario, about 36.6 mi (58.9 km) east of Rochester and 54.5 mi (87.7 km) northwest of Syracuse. People who live in the area know Sodus Point is a fantastic place for fishing and boating, making it an ideal summer getaway. Moreover, it’s home to several attractions. One of these is Sodus Point Beach Park, located at the town’s tip. It is equipped with a playground, showers, and grilling area, perfect for a fun family day out. Just nearby is Sodus Bay Lighthouse Museum where you can learn more about Sodus Point’s maritime history.
If you’re looking for a quiet place to holiday, Sodus Point, with its natural beauty and picture-worthy marina, is it. Scroll below for the best Airbnb vacation rentals in Sodus Point, New York.
We handpicked these listings carefully, considering (wherever possible) Superhost status, recent guest reviews, location, accommodation type, prices, availability of dates, decor, and amenities. The image galleries get refreshed with the latest updates regularly. They were last updated on April 14, 2024.
1. Crown Nest at The Wickham House Inn (from USD 125)
For your trip, consider reserving this lovely room at The Wickham House Inn. It’s a studio apartment furnished with the essentials including an air conditioner to keep you cool during your stay. A kitchenette, which comes with a coffee maker and toaster, is also available for your use. You’ll have your own private entrance, as well as a reserved parking slot on the east side of the inn.
From here, you can walk to Sodus Point Lighthouse and beach park. Furthermore, the downtown area is also a short walk away from here.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
the bed was comfy with a pillow topper and we slept greatwe had a great stay at the crows nest this upstairs apartment was perfect for the two of usCleanliness:
everything was very clean as wellthe most clean and quiet place ever i sleptthe room was very clean and perfect for a long weekend getawaythe apartment was so clean and cuteclean well-equipped charming little placeHost:
margaret was very responsive to our questions prior to the visitmargaret was very helpful with any questionsmargaret was very helpful with check in and responsive when neededmargaret is friendly and ready to help with any of your needssuch a great place the stay the hosts are amazing and it’s the nicest spotRead more reviewsLocation:
super cute and great locationeasy walking distance to a few restaurantsgreat location and great pricesafe and convenient locationthe neighborhood was cute and very quiet
2. Spacious log cabin (from USD 294)
At first glance, this Airbnb rental appears to be small and cozy. However, inside, it’s a very roomy home, spacious enough for a large family or group. The main living floor has an open flow where everyone can gather, cook, and eat simultaneously. Besides that, on cooler nights, light the gas fireplace to keep the place toasty. But on warmer days, cool air circulates throughout the cabin thanks to the property’s central air conditioning.
Outside, the yard is just as spacious, with two gas grills and a fire pit area. There’s also plenty of space for a game of baseball.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
the living room furniture could use updating but i would definitely rent here againa/c working great water pressure is excellentlots of room very comfortable a/c and loved the back yardyou can swim with the waves of lake ontario or the calm sandy beaches of sodus bayCleanliness:
it was clean and spaciousgreat communication rustic clean house everything better than we imaginedamazing very clean with plenty of room for gathering with friends and familybeautiful spacious cabin for like 15-20 people neat and clean at a gorgeous locationHost:
our host was fantasticowners were very responsivehosts were very nice and accommodatinghosts were very accommodating quick to respond and very friendlyhosts are great easy to communicate withRead more reviewsLocation:
the location is greatthe location is perfectgreat place and great locationall around great house and locationgreat house great location
Superhost
3. Fish Mode Lodge (from USD 110)
Sports enthusiasts - especially boaters, hikers, and anglers - will love Fish Mode Lodge. This Airbnb vacation rental is only a short distance away from great fishing spots as well as hiking trails and other fun water activities on Lake Ontario. Furthermore, if you brought a boat, you’ll be pleased to know that this Airbnb is also near a public boat launch.
Part of the property is a deck with plenty of sitting arrangements and a grill, where you can hang out and have fun cookouts. It overlooks the backyard, so you can have your morning coffee here and take in the gorgeous views. Also, no need to bring linens here as they’re already provided.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
no cell service but excellent wifistayed cool though by sleeping in the living roomthe barbecue grill was great for cooking and the picnic table made enjoying our food outside even betterCleanliness:
the place was spotlessly cleaneverything was so clean and nicewell cared for and exceptionally cleangreat place clean and convenient locationit’s a very clean and well kept trailer that is in a perfect location in sodus pointHost:
sharon is very communicative and kindhosts were very communicative and helpfulclair was an excellent hostthe hosts communicated well and helped us with a special requestcheck-in was simple and the host was helpfulRead more reviewsLocation:
great location near waterconvenient location good bargainconvenient location to many local attractions and storesnice place and close to townreally great location for sodus point
4. The Cottage at The Lodge (from USD 181)
Just as its name implies, this Airbnb rental provides cozy accommodations, albeit on the more modern side. That’s because The Cottage was recently remodeled. Some of the upgrades include an open living area. The property is fully furnished and also fitted with high-speed Wi-Fi, perfect for those who need to work remotely. On-site free parking is available here as well.
This pet-friendly property also has a 55-inch TV loaded with popular streaming services and a Firestick, so you will have limitless entertainment options even while indoors.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
we enjoyed our stay at the "cottage" apartmentCleanliness:
very clean nice place to stayvery clean and accurate listingvery cozy clean and practicalthe house was very clean and very easy to access once we arrivedthere was plenty of room and the space was very cleanHost:
host was responsive and very helpfulmatthew was very helpful and made sure we had everything we neededwe had a wonderful girls weekend and we met the ownerthe host (matt) was very informative and easy to communicate withmatt responds very quickly is very polite and wonderfully accommodatingRead more reviewsLocation:
place was great close to everythinggreat location right in the heart of sodus pointnice walk to lighthousewalking distance to a lot of fun things to dolocation is the best everything is nearby
5. Cheerful lakefront cottage (from USD 221)
Lake Ontario is part of your playground if you stay in this Airbnb rental. The main highlight of this property is the outdoor space where a fire pit was recently installed, so you can have a cozy time with your family under the stars. Furthermore, if you’re bringing your dogs with you, the hosts also added a dedicated dog run so they can play safely.
Walking further on, you’ll find the 50.0-ft (15.2 m) dock - the perfect launchpad for cannonballs straight onto the lake. Also, if you’re feeling adventurous, paddle out to a sandbar located not far from the shore.
Top guest reviews
Cleanliness:
very clean and well organizedhouse was clean and well stocked with everything you neededhouse was beautifully decorated and very cleancleanliness was definitely noticed thank you for a wonderful weekend to add to out families memoriesprime location beautiful sunrise in the morning clean interior lots of fun for my family of fourHost:
the hosts were easy to communicate with and responded quickly to any questionsmichelle and jeremy were wonderful hosts the house was beautifully decorated and updatedi am not too familiar with airbnb the hosts made it very easythe home being dog friendly was so nice as wellwe had great communication with the home owners and our stay was just perfectRead more reviewsLocation:
this was a great location convenient to many restaurantsgreat location in sodus point walking distance to restaurants ice cream etcwe had a great time right on the water and a nice place for a large group
6. Cute bayfront cottage (from USD 120)
This waterfront Airbnb rental is a calming place to be in Sodus Point. It overlooks Sodus Bay and offers outstanding fishing opportunities for avid anglers. Wintertime is also a fantastic time to stay here, especially for ice-fishing enthusiasts or those who want to try it out. That said, the rental is fully furnished with all seasons in mind. Both central air conditioning and heating are available.
Furthermore, on clear and beautiful days, enjoy your meals in the outdoor dining area. There are barbecue equipment available too, so feel free to grill your catch of the day and enjoy it with your family.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
great place to stay quiet cozy and beautiful viewsabsolutely loved our stay loved the cottage decorated beautifully comfortable and felt right at homeCleanliness:
it was very clean and comfortableit was very clean and invitinggreat place to stay very clean and accommodatingit was clean clutter-free and comfortablethe cottage was very clean cute and as advertisedHost:
and they were very helpful with all our questionsgreat host super helpful and friendly- and the place is great too definitely recommendhis uncle steve lives next door and is friendly and also wanting to assure a great staywith a 9 month old having a friendly host was our number one priorityluke is great at answering your questions in a timely fashion and is very accommodatingRead more reviewsLocation:
perfect location felt exactly like a cute getaway placecute comfortable quiet and perfectly located house a few minutes away (walking) from the lakegreat location and luke's place was definitely exactly as described
7. The Boat House at Coal Trestle Cove (from USD 204)
The Boat House at Coal Trestle Cove makes great use of its location on Sodus Bay. It has a backyard deck situated right on the water. From this perch, you’ll have front-row seats to Sodus Point sunrises as you enjoy your morning brew.
Additionally, feel free to spend most of your time here watching the boats go by, but if you want to experience Lake Ontario, there are three marinas located near the rental. And if ever you run out of drinks, a local liquor store is just down the road.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
the mattress was very comfortable and the shower was fantasticCleanliness:
very modern and clean interiorclean airy comfortable and well keptthe boathouse was so clean and cozybeautiful place to stay at clean classy and a very luxuriouseverything is brand new and very cleanHost:
super attentive hosthosts were so friendly and accommodatinggreat place and an amazing hostour hosts were accommodating and could not have been more helpfulthe hosts are so accomodating and amazingly friendlyRead more reviewsLocation:
great place and walking distance to everythingawesome location and awesome peopleit’s close enough to everything but felt like an oasis to return toa great place for a long-weekend break from the day to daythis place is so cute and perfect for a solo or couple getaway
8. Pet-friendly apartment (from USD 113)
Check out this lovely rental apartment in Sodus Point. It’s on the first floor of a pastel-yellow home. For a small fee, you can even bring your pet (and their bed) with you on holiday. The property is also fitted with a level two electric vehicle charger that you can use if that’s the type of car you brought.
As a guest, you’ll have access to the laundry facilities too. You’ll also have private living spaces and basically, the entire first floor is yours during your stay.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
mark was a super host with a delightful apartment that has views of the baythe kitchen was well stocked and the mattress was extremely comfortable following a 30 mile bike rideCleanliness:
lovely very clean and comfortablehis place was clean and well-appointedthe apartment was fresh and cleanthe place was great it was clean and everything was decorated niceclean secure good price and well appointedHost:
mark is a wonderful hostmark was a great accommodating hostmark was super responsive with the reservation and getting us inmark is a great host and the house is adorablethe host was not only responsive but proactive we felt comfortable there for our entire stayRead more reviewsLocation:
great location…easy walking distance to our family members and restaurants on the pointfood and entertainment within walking distancemark’s apartment is perfect the location is sublimenice place close to downtown worth the pricegreat location and perfect size for a little getaway
9. Rustic loft apartment (from USD 140)
This Airbnb rental loves to surprise with its decor and amenities. When you open the door, you’ll be greeted by a rustic-modern space with beautiful wooden floors and ceilings. Pick your favorite chair by the window: a big leather couch or wood rocking chair. Whichever you pick, you’ll be able to admire views of Sodus Bay from inside the loft.
Moreover, you’ll have your own private entrance. And, if you’re bringing a boat, there are multiple parking spots for trailers available. You’ll also be able to use the host’s docks which are just across the street. If you’re not bringing any but would still like to go on the lake, you can rent a pontoon boat from the host.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
quaint lake/cabin themed apartment with nice view of the waterthis is very nice apartment with a great view of the lakevery cute clean cozy place with great view of lake from apartment and balconywas great to return to the air-conditioned apartment after a hot day on the beacha true gem on sodus point we absolutely loved our stay comfortable clean and cozy with a beautiful viewCleanliness:
clean cozy accommodationsit was both clean and dog friendly which we lovedlaurie's place was very clean and comfortablethe place was very clean and was an efficient use of spacevery clean with everything you could possibly need for a weekend getawayHost:
the host are superlaurie was a great hostlaurie is a great hostlaurie is a great hostthe host was very responsiveRead more reviewsLocation:
a great place in a great locationclose to everything from excellent golf to great places to eat etcthe location was perfect i loved the apartmentthe property has a superb locationlaurie's place is a wonderful getaway close enough to activities in town but in a quiet location
10. Jameson Bay Inn (from USD 199)
Jameson Bay Inn is unique in that unlike most inns, the entire property is up for rent. You and your companions can enjoy hotel-level amenities and touches here, such as double shower heads and an en-suite hot tub. Other than that, from several points of this Airbnb, you can admire views of Sodus Bay.
If you want to be closer to the water, there’s a private dock you use for fishing or parking your boat. The yard is also a fantastic spot to play a few games or just catch a few rays.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
the kitchen had everything we needed and the jacuzzi bath was greatCleanliness:
very clean and great communicationsparkly clean and we'll stocked with cooking utensils and dishesvery clean and well kept homehouse was clean and well cared forthis place was great beautiful view with clean rooms and clean bathroomsHost:
beautiful property and the owner is friendly and easy to communicate withthe hosts are gracious and friendly but also very respectful of privacysuper host would highly recommendlaurie was very responsive and the place was spotlessamazing hosts of a beautiful home on sodus bay — thank you jim & laurieRead more reviewsLocation:
very nice location and staygreat location—close to restaurants stores pier and beachthe location was great- we enjoyed being able to walk to the beachgreat stay perfect location will definitely be returningbeautiful home in a great location
Make your new happy place in Sodus Point
With great low-key attractions and a bevy of comfortable Airbnb rentals, one thing is clear. Sodus Point may very well be your next go-to destination for easy holidays by the lake. For a memorable vacation here, book any of the rentals mentioned in this list!
History
Get Trip101 in your inbox
Unsubscribe in one click. See our Privacy Policy for more information on how we use your data
Create an account to