Home to the City of Dreams, New York City, as well as a variety of other amazing tourist destinations, the state of New York is a giant when it comes to vacation destinations. Whether you wish to visit the glittering urban attractions of downtown Manhattan, check out the natural scenic beauty of the towering Niagara Falls north of the city, or the serene and tranquil Finger Lakes, Lake George or Lake Placid, there is something for everyone in this state. If you are into adventure sports, the Catskills are a must-visit destination in the state. Lastly, history buffs can check out National Baseball Hall of Fame and Museum and George Eastman House. With so much to explore during your stay, why not treat yourself to a historic hotel that has a story to tell? Read on to explore the best historic hotels in New York, USA!
We handpicked these listings carefully, considering (wherever possible) properties with historic significance, recent guest reviews, location, accommodation type, prices, availability of dates, decor, and amenities. The image galleries get refreshed with the latest updates regularly. They were last updated on October 30, 2025.
1. Wythe Hotel, Brooklyn (from USD 550)
Amazing dining experiences including a fantastic French restaurant and a vibrant rooftop bar.
Reasonable pricing for spacious, well-designed rooms with stunning views.
Ideal location in Williamsburg, close to NYC ferry and great dining and shopping options.
Fantastic rooftop bar, French restaurant, and spacious, stylish rooms.
Converted into a luxurious four-star hotel from a century-old factory, this beautiful accommodation is situated right on the Brooklyn waterfront and offers panoramic views of New York City. The hotel exhibits architectural elements that have been preserved from the Edwardian era, such as exposed brick walls, industrial-style beams and large windows overlooking the waterfront.
The ceilings in all the rooms feature timber beams, and the rooms also boast heated concrete floors. You can enjoy your meals at the on-site restaurant or opt for handcrafted cocktails at Bar Blondeau.
Wythe Hotel This is a Proud Certified property where you can be extra sure of a welcoming stay.
Address: 80 Wythe Avenue
65.52 km (40.8 mi) from Bear Mountain State Park
2. Red Coach Inn, Niagara Falls (from USD 367)
Situated in Niagara Falls, this historic lodging offers a quaint and charming experience if you wish to opt for a more authentic historical experience. Red Coach Inn has been providing luxury accommodation to its guests since 1923, and it features English Tudor-style design elements throughout the property and an English country vibe that will transport you to another time.
Enjoy a variety of accommodation packages, including romance, tour or dinner, and make the most of your stay here.
Red Coach Inn
Address: 2 Buffalo Avenue, Niagara Falls City Center, Niagara Falls (NY), United States, NY 14303
462.09 km (287.2 mi) from Bear Mountain State Park
3. Queensbury Hotel, Glens Galls (from USD 159)
Constructed in 1926, this historic building that’s been turned into a hotel is situated in downtown Glens Falls, close to Lake George and Saratoga Springs.
The hotel has been running for close to a century and features old-world charm combined with modern amenities for the contemporary guest. You can enjoy a choice of premium accommodations designed to make your stay extremely comfortable, including deluxe rooms and luxury suites. The hotel also has a luxurious spa centre, free WiFi and a swimming pool with a hot tub.
The Queensbury Hotel
Address: 88 Ridge Street
224.35 km (139.5 mi) from Bear Mountain State Park
4. Oheka Castle Hotel & Estate, Huntington (from USD 535)
Situated close to both the beachfront and the suburbs, this beautiful hotel with 100 years of history was once a castle. It features a sprawling estate close to Planting Fields Arboretum State Historic Park.
The hotel offers a choice of rooms that are individually decorated. The property is the perfect wedding destination as it invokes a classic old-fashioned charm. Breakfast is available, and amenities include a spa, a fitness centre, and valet parking.
Oheka Castle Hotel & Estate
Address: 135 W Gate Dr
70.15 km (43.6 mi) from Bear Mountain State Park
New York Tour Guide
Annie Leguennec
My name is Annie. I am a local Tour guide based in Philadelphia enjoying fully what the city has to offer with its deep history, street arts, murals, architecture, traditional food, black history, Farmer Markets, green space, a melting pot of neighborhoods and its great locals. I am looking for to welcome you and show you this incredible city where you will gain a better understanding of the ci... Read more
Tours by Annie
5. JW Marriott Essex House New York (from USD 744)
Mixed reviews on hotel dining, with some guests finding the food overpriced and underwhelming.
High pricing for spacious rooms and Central Park views.
Fantastic location opposite Central Park, with easy access to attractions and restaurants.
Comfortable beds, large rooms, helpful staff, but no in-room coffee or complimentary water.
Who hasn’t heard of the world-famous JW Marriott group of hotels? Constructed in 1931, JW Marriott Essex House New York features elements dating back to that time, with a sophisticated Art Deco design reflected throughout the space.
Situated in Manhattan, this hotel offers a variety of rooms and suites to choose from depending on your preference, and it features amazing on-site amenities such as a spa centre with a choice of wellness packages, an on-site restaurant and a contemporary fitness centre.
JW Marriott Essex House New York
Address: 160 Central Park South
60.54 km (37.7 mi) from Bear Mountain State Park
6. Martinique New York on Broadway, Curio Collection by Hilton (from USD 407)
Delicious breakfast, limited menu, expensive, but friendly service and great for people-watching.
High rates for small rooms, hidden fees, but $30 daily credit for food.
Prime location in Midtown Manhattan, close to subway, popular tourist spots, and Korean restaurants, but noisy and crowded outside.
Clean, well-maintained, friendly staff, convenient parking, but small rooms and limited in-room accessories.
Featuring a breathtakingly beautiful French Renaissance décor style, this luxury four-star hotel offers an extraordinary experience for its patrons and is listed among the historic hotels in the city of New York. Situated in Midtown Manhattan, this hotel offers relaxing accommodation in the form of rooms and suites, complete with all the classic amenities of a luxury hotel such as a coffee maker, complimentary WiFi and a laptop-friendly workspace.
Invoking the understated luxury of modern-day hotels combined with the glamour and romance of yesteryear, this hotel is run by the Hilton group and is ideal for history buffs who want an elevated experience.
Martinique New York on Broadway, Curio Collection by Hilton This is a Proud Certified property where you can be extra sure of a welcoming stay.
Address: 49 West 32nd Street
62.55 km (38.9 mi) from Bear Mountain State Park
7. Overlook Lodge at Bear Mountain (from USD 169)
Let’s face it: the urban frenzy of New York City isn’t something a lot of us want to experience while on vacation. This cosy lodging offers a comfortable stay in the lap of nature and overlooks the beautiful Hudson River. It’s also a historic property, listed on the National and New York State Registers of Historic Places.
Enjoy a rustic design style with handcrafted wood furnishings at Overlook Lodge, or stay in the romantic detached stone cottages with a queen-sized bed and a stone fireplace.
Overlook Lodge and Stone Cottages at Bear Mountain
Address: 55 Hessian Drive
1.16 km (0.8 mi) from Bear Mountain State Park
8. Iroquois New York Times Square (from USD 175)
Situated a stone’s throw away from Times Square in Midtown Manhattan, this amazing hotel offers world-class hospitality in a historic setting and has been providing sophisticated lodging for over a century. Designed in 1899 and opened in 1902, this hotel has been frequented by local artists and actors of yesteryear.
You can choose between rooms or suites, and the property offers all the classic amenities of a five-star accommodation. You can also enjoy vintage services such as turndown service, newspaper delivery, bathrobes, bellman and concierge services and overnight shoeshine service.
Iroquois New York Times Square
Address: 49 West 44th Street
61.71 km (38.4 mi) from Bear Mountain State Park
9. Henry Norman Hotel, Brooklyn (from USD 200)
This four-star historic hotel is situated in Brooklyn and boasts panoramic views of the New York skyline from its large windows. This hotel has been converted from what was once a textile warehouse dating back to the 19th century, and it offers individually decorated boutique rooms with all the classic amenities of a luxury hotel.
It includes an on-site dining area where you can enjoy delicious meals. You can start the day at the fitness centre and end it by relaxing on the terrace and enjoying the sunset views.
Henry Norman Hotel This is a Proud Certified property where you can be extra sure of a welcoming stay.
Address: 239 North Henry Street
64.92 km (40.4 mi) from Bear Mountain State Park
10. Marriott Syracuse Downtown (from USD 389)
This is another Marriott property that boasts incredible amenities in a historic building with old-world architecture and handpainted murals. Marriott Syracuse Downtown was constructed in 1924 and was recently renovated to pay homage to its original glory.
It is close to a variety of local attractions in the area, including Armory Square, The Oncenter, and more. You can enjoy dining at one of the two on-site restaurants, host meetings at the business centre or stay fit at the on-site gym.
Marriott Syracuse Downtown
Address: 100 East Onondaga Street
262.55 km (163.2 mi) from Bear Mountain State Park
Transport yourself to another time during your stay in New York
The state of New York offers a plethora of amazing historic hotels with an appealing vintage charm. With historic architecture and design styles dating back to the Edwardian and Victorian eras, these hotels aim to provide a comfortable experience by combining the old and the new. Book your accommodations today and make the most of your upcoming trip to New York!
History
Get Trip101 in your inbox
Unsubscribe in one click. See our Privacy Policy for more information on how we use your data